Media

Streaming Media Sucks Donkey Plasma

Tuesday, March 20th, 2007

Net connections are not good from Beijing. How not good? So not good that whenever I try to watch any streaming media clip, such as anything on youtube, the New York Times, Salon.com’s Video Dog, the embedded video clips on Robert Scoble’s blog, etc; On any of these I can only see a few seconds of video at a time with long stretches of still frames while reading text that says “Buffering 6%”, “Buffering 11%”, “Buffering 14%”, etc.

Salon.com’s flash-based media player is the worst of the lot. With many streaming media players, if I get tired of watching the video in 2 second bursts, I can just walk away and read the latest Harry Potter novel, then return, rewind the clip, and watch the now-fully-buffered clip in its entirety. The player for Salon.com’s video dog, if left alone for a bit, apparently erases its buffer and jumps back to the beginning of the clip. Thus, unless I’m prepared to sit there and monitor the buffering of the clip and hit the rewind and play buttons during the window of opportunity, I do not get to see the clip at all.

Speaking of streaming media, “goodbye and good luck” to Calvert DeForest (AKA Larry “Bud” Melman), we hardly knew ye

The existence of this clip illustrates the value of the common archive that occurs when ordinary people are given the ability to record and preserve media, hooray for VHS.

I believe there are reasons to provide streaming media, which I’ll explain below, but any instance of streaming media on a web page should always be accompanied by a link that users can click to download the video as a file.

I wrote to Salon.com a year ago, asking if they would please make their video files available for download, not just as streams. They responded that this was not possible because the videos contain bits of copyrighted media. This is an unnecessary and particularly gutless bit of rationalization. Salon.com is a publication and can easily justify its redistribution of these excerpts of tv shows as commentary, protected as “fair use” under U.S. copyright law. Their stance is both gutless and bizarre –in what way is providing media on which you do not own the copyright any better when provided as a stream rather than a file? I guess we’ll find out for sure if YouTube tries the “but we only provide streaming media” defense in the billion dollar Viacom vs. YouTube lawsuit.

Ranting aside, I admit there is one very good reason to use streaming media on a site. With a good net conection, playback of streaming media starts instantly and requires no download. Not only does playback of streaming media begin just after the user clicks the media, but the better streaming servers (QuickTime, Windows Media) can adjust the bandwidth of the video to match the user’s net speed. It is of course, also possible for playback of certain kinds of downloaded files to begin immediately (QuickTime files), but not with the same level of bandwidth control.

But another reason to use streaming media is dumb and evil. The logic probably goes something like this

If I, the company hosting the video, provide a file to users as a stream and not as a download, then the user can’t keep the file and do nefarious things with it. Thus I keep the level of control I desperately need over the media and its distribution.

Dumb dumb dumb. This begins with the assumption that people who plan to watch the video you provide have criminal intentions that can be thwarted by not providing them with an actual video file. It’s that kind of lack of trust that leads to unnecessary technological stumbling blocks that just make things more difficult for ordinary non-criminal users. And the stumbling blocks are annoying rather than effective –the desired level of control over a stream is barely possible (for the moment it’s possible to surreptitiously download video files from YouTube and some other streaming flash sites, and I am grateful, because otherwise I would never be able to watch these videos).

So while it’s great that users are putting more and more video online, it is unfortunate that much of this video is available only as streaming media, which us reasonably law abiding users can’t put on an ipod, and can only watch in excruciatingly low quality (due to streaming servers’ bandwidth control features) on sub-amazing net connections if at all.

On the bright side, due to the popularity of the iPod and other mp4 video devices (I’m trying to not be a total Apple partisan here), plus the fact that Apple put podcasting features and a free and easy to use podcast directory into their ubiquitous iTunes software (gotta give ’em huge props for that), downloadable video files are becoming much more common. I found a video podcast of the aforementioned Scoble show in the iTunes Music Store’s podcast directory. These are downloadable mp4 versions of the same video clips I could not watch as inline streaming flash video on the Scobleizer blog. The New York Times also puts many of its video clips online in a series of video podcasts, though they inexplicably miss the ones I’d actually like to watch, like the video about Chinese adoptee Cece Nealon-Shapiro’s bat mitzvah, which is only available as a stream.

Everything I’ve said above also applies to audio streams. The Recidivism blog republished NPR’s great Fresh Air interview with Sacha Baron Cohen as an mp3 file. Previously it was available only from NPR’s site as a stream and as that blogger says “Streams are completely useless when I’m trying to use my device (acrylic push-button model) in the car”. A comment on that blog post mentions that NPR has taken the audio stream down, so the existence of this user-hosted mp3 file may be the only way to hear the interview. This is a great example of two reasons why such files should be available for download rather than just as streams: users should be able to listen to such audio clips on the device of their choosing, and interesting files can have more staying power if they are not only hosted as streams that might be taken down at any moment. Imagine the photographic evidence of history that would be lost if all daguerrotypes had only been available for viewing in one building, which then burned to the ground.

Greetings from Nanjing

Monday, February 5th, 2007

floatable foam Nanjing dead
More specifically, greetings from a recreation of 1930s Nanjing under Japanese occupation, created here at Hengdian World Studios (near Shanghai). Seen in this photo are a few “corpses” (foam) that were a few minutes previously floating in the “Yangtze river” (pool). Ah, the magic of filmmaking.

Music on my mind, mid-January 2007

Sunday, January 21st, 2007

I’ve been hard at work lately on several projects: A website, some film-related I.T. work, and have started preproduction planning on a music video I’ll be directing. As often happens when I’m engaged in other pursuits, musical themes intrude into my head and I have to go buy them and listen repeatedly . This time it’s the nihilist pop of Ladytron, with a track by Martin Gore on heavy rotation as well:

Song Album Artist
Evil Light & Magic Ladytron
Seventeen Light & Magic Ladytron
Destroy Everything You Touch Witching Hour Ladytron
Playgirl Commodore Rock Ladytron
The Reason Why Light & Magic Ladytron
Discotraxx 604 Ladytron
Compulsion Counterfeit [EP] Martin Gore

If you think these tracks are easy to find in Beijing, you should by rights be wrong. However, almost as quickly as the songs popped into my head, I ran into people who had all of these albums.

This playlist could be entitled “music for not smiling”. Despite the inhumanly mechanical musical textures, this kind of music often broadcasts more emotional content to me than songs with more inflected and showy vocal and instrumental stylings. These and other musical artists of today should be commended for confusing the historian bots of the future, who will likely one day uncover these albums and have huge debates lasting milliseconds over whether or not the tracks were released before or after all humans died out and were replaced by robots.

China From the Inside

Thursday, January 11th, 2007

I would love to see this new 4-hour documentary about China made for Granada-KQED-PBS-BBC entitled China From the Inside.

From the article:

The footage is vast. Cameras traveled to Tibet; Xinjiang, home to many Muslims; the Kazakhstan border; the Gobi Desert; and the Yangtze River. There are interviews with women activists trying to instill self-confidence among rural women (to try to help stave off a high suicide rate); a National People’s Congress delegate comparing communism with U.S. democracy; a Catholic priest practicing religion in an atheist country; and residents who’ve been displaced by the gargantuan construction of the Three Gorges Dam.
…an environmental activist talks about the polluted Huai River, its cancer-inducing contaminants ravaging the lives of villagers whose photos he displays. In the segment about women, a factory worker in Guangdong Province talking about her day-to-day life: Working the assembly line and prohibited from talking between 6:08 a.m. and 6:08 p.m.

It’s no surprise that the Chinese government was a little concerned about the making of this documentary, but it sounds as though the government minders assigned to this project deserve much respect for making excuses and leaving the set when sensitive topics were being covered. The fact that the documentary’s director had previously made a 4-part documentary entitled “Hell in the Pacific” about the Nanjing massacre by the Japanese probably helped him get reasonably free access to cover sensitive locations, people, and topics.

Thanks to <shamus> for the link.

The “real” press is in competition with The Onion. BRITNEY SLEEPS!

Monday, January 1st, 2007

When serious journalists at the Associated Press push out headlines like Spears falls asleep in Vegas nightclub, I’m not sure there’s any room left for humorists.

By about one o’clock, she was just done, so we took her out,” Spears’ manager, Larry Rudolph, told The Associated Press Monday. “She was not drunk. She was just tired and falling asleep.

I love the hilarious fake newspaper The Onion, but at this point the real press is indulging in such self-parody to give that humor rag a run for its money.

Modern Dance at the China Open

Sunday, October 29th, 2006

M. Berrer crouches on the court

M. Berrer strikes a dramatic pose after returning the ball (and ultimately losing the match) to Hyung-Taik Lee in the 2006 China Open on 2006-9-13.

I’ll be posting a few more photos from this match because it was the first professional tennis match I’ve ever attended and some of the photos came out nicely.

A trip to the wild West of China

Saturday, October 21st, 2006
MyPictureinteresting places, interesting hats

MyPicture-1A Kyrgyz village along the shore of Lake Karakul
more Xinjiang photos…

The October holiday has come and gone. During the October holiday, tons of Chinese people get a week of vacation and go traveling. Lisa and I left Beijing and headed far West to the Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region. We stopped by Urumqi, Turfan, Kashgar, Lake Karakul, and Tashkurgan. That last town being only 120km from the Pakistani border. We stayed with a Uighur family in a farmhouse in Turfan, a Kyrgyz family in a Yurt at Lake Karakul, and visited the grand bazaar in Kashgar.

Because we travelled during the month of Ramadan, most of the people we met were fasting during the daytime. They would eat breakfast around 4:00 AM, fast all day, and then eat again after sundown. When we hired a driver in Kashgar for our two day trip to Lake Karakul and Tashkurgan, I felt a little guilty eating within his presence. I compensated by only drinking water and eating an unappetizing Chinese confection labelled “milk chocolate replacer” while in his car. If you ever encounter this candy, I would not recommend purchasing it.

MyPicture-2
20 RMB per pillow?! How about 5?

The Kashgar Sunday Market, or grand bazaar, feels like a place left alone by time. Tens of thousands of vendors of many ethnicities travel to this silk road oasis once a week from outlying areas, many on donkey-carts, to sell produce, livestock, medicinal items, hats, shoes, cloth, huge 80s-era boomboxes, you name it. It is a great place to practice bargaining. Try to get that 180RMB shirt marked down to 40RMB for two. You’ll probably only need to begin walking away twice. It’s fun, and the rule.

MyPicture-2
A Kyrgyz girl washes dishes in her family’s Yurt

If you ever visit China for more than a week or two, I’d highly recommend a trip to Xinjiang and other old silk road towns. It’s great to see a part of China that is so very different from the metropolitan and largely Han Chinese cities of Beijing and Shanghai. It is also interesting to be stared at — something I experienced several times in Xinjiang but rarely experience in the more international city of Beijing. At Lake Karakul a giggling Chinese tourist even ran up and asked me to stand next to her in a photo. It was a strange feeling to stand out as if I were some sort of tourist attraction. Perhaps that’s what the Kyrgyz people at Lake Karakul felt like when the Karakoram highway was paved and the Chinese tourists began showing up to take photos of the yurts they call home.

I’ve placed some photos of the trip in an online gallery.

The HP Zone

Sunday, September 24th, 2006
the slimming feature in the menu of an HP photosmart camera
Hey! Number Twelve Looks Just Like You

HP is run by geniuses. Not only have they demonstrated that they can think far far out of the box in their attempts to determine who amongst them have been leaking stories to the press, but they’ve also added a fantastic new feature to their digital cameras: The “Slimming Effect”. Here’s a heavily-edited excerpt from that HP web page which explains how to use the feature:

Imagine a time in the future when science has developed a means of giving everyone the face and body he dreams of. It may not happen tomorrow–but it nearly happens now in your new HP Photosmart camera, and at the push of a button!

  1. Take a self-portrait. Then…Highlight the Design Gallery menu tab…
  2. …highlight Apply Artistic Effects and press OK. Then highlight Slimming and press OK.
  3. Adjust the slimming level using the arrows. Then press OK, and you’re finished.

In order to use this feature, all you have to do is have someone take your photo, press the camera’s OK button a few times, and then HP’s sophisticated software takes over. It analyzes the photo to determine your body mass index and map your fat distribution. The software then compares these measurements against the “Los Angeles” database of preferred body shapes and sizes, and notes any discrepancies.

Next, the camera then calculates the degree of “slimming” that it can safely perform to your image –for most of us there’s no limit, heck even models and stars get heavily retouched and reshaped these days. Even Britney Spears.

But for some users too much virtual slimming and they might risk falling into depression the next time they look in the mirror and rediscover their non-virtual self. These particularly sensitive users will be encouraged to purchase HP’s “slimming mirror”, due out next year.

With ideas as valuable as these, is it any wonder that HP’s board of directors would do anything in their power to stop press leaks.

Not every film featuring puppets is for kids

Monday, September 11th, 2006
a shelf of videos in a Beijing DVD storeAmerica, F@#! Yeah!

I am fairly certain that the film Team America: World Police, which features tons of puppet violence and sex, should never be placed on the Children’s shelf at a video store. However, nobody listens to me here.

I’ve seen this video on the children’s shelf in two different video stores now, so it’s no anomaly. Either Chinese video store employees are making a point of not watching the film, or they have very different standards for what constitutes an acceptable level of beheadings and scatological references in films for children.

Informer

Friday, August 11th, 2006

Some guy actually listened to the early 90’s song Informer, by Snow, for six hours non-stop. I know I’m a year late in passing along my appreciation, but wow. This man’s one act undoubtedly caused a rupture in the space-time continuum.

For those of you who don’t remember the song, it’s a sort of gangland anthem sung in an impenetrable and speedy Jamaican patois by a Canadian white guy whose name is not really Snow. I think the only word I can understand in the entire song is “Informer”, everything else is an interestingly syncopated blur. The song was pretty catchy back in the day, and was #1 for a while on some chart, but now people remember it as an oddity if at all.

There’s a reason I just now remembered the existence of this song and did the net searching that led to discovery of the 2005 Snow marathon, and it’s not that I’m just trying to distract myself from thinking about the fun I’m going to have going through airport security on Monday for my trip to the U.S. The real reason is that a good friend stopped by Beijing for a visit. He hooked his iPod up to my stereo, and in rotation along with a bunch of forgotten songs from the 80s and 90s was Informer. We listened to it once, which was pleasant, but I can’t imagine what 6 hours of Informer could do to a person.
(Don’t remember the song? You can hear a clip at iTunes, or Amazon)