Audio

The Bluetooth Car Audio Streaming Conundrum

Tuesday, March 25th, 2014
This is the story of the journey I’ve taken to my current car audio streaming solution, and the devices I’ve tried and abandoned along the way. Maybe some of this information will be of use to you, as it describes solutions and pitfalls related to the bluetooth streaming of audio from a phone or tablet to a car stereo. A followup post will describe how to do it better.

Sometimes one just needs to take a break from endless projects and geekery and just go for a drive and listen to some music. It’s the American way to hit the road and then hit play. That phone you carry around is just waiting to play tons of high quality music from its gargantuan internal storage, or stream music from the net as if you’re living in the post-cloud era.

We Want Wireless


But what’s that you say? Your car doesn’t have built-in bluetooth music streaming, and it’s annoying to have to connect a cable from your phone jack to your car stereo’s aux input every time you get in the car? Maybe you’re worried about wearing-out the phone’s headphone jack, or you’d rather be able to run a true line-level output to the car stereo’s aux input 1 The simple answer is to just buy a Bluetooth car audio receiver such as the Soundfly BT, which plugs right into your car’s cigarette lighter outlet or whatever they call that port these days 2. The Soundfly BT will power up with your car, your paired phone will automatically redirect its audio output to it via the Bluetooth A2DP service, and music will play from the Soundfly BT’s line out port to your car stereo’s aux input or it’ll broadcast to your car stereo’s radio receiver using the device’s built-in FM transmitter.

Apart from the fact that bluetooth audio transmission uses lossy compression 3 and theoretically could degrade the audio a bit, this thing sounds great and is a pretty ideal solution. Unless, that is, your car is like mine, and features an excellent built-in bluetooth speakerphone system that you’d like to continue to use.

Trouble in Paradise: The Bluetooth Speakerphone War

Because the Soundfly BT also features a (horrible) mic and can be used as a speakerphone, it has registered itself with your paired phone as both a Hands-Free and an A2DP audio streaming device. The. Horror.

Your new bluetooth music receiver and your car speakerphone are now at war.

Here’s how this situation regularly played out for me: I’d be in my car in bumper to bumper traffic on the 101 and I’d get a call about a job. I’d hit the answer button on my steering wheel, and my car’s bluetooth speakerphone would answer the call. I’d hear the caller’s perfectly-clear voice on the car’s dedicated hands-free speaker for about 2 seconds, and then 6 times out of 10 everything would go eerily silent in the middle of a word. My phone had just switched from using the car’s hands free system to the Soundfly BT’s hands free system. If my car stereo was set to play from its aux input, there would be a second of silence as the connection switched and then I’d hear (coming from the stereo) the concerned caller repeating my name adorned with question marks. I’d talk back and they’d barely able to make out what I’m saying because of the aforementioned awful mic.

Driving in Songjiang, a suburb of Shanghai.
Keep your eyes on the road! (Especially if you’re driving in Songjiang, a suburb of Shanghai)
That was the best-case-scenario with the Soundfly BT in my car. It didn’t go so well if my stereo was not already set to the aux input, because this meant that in order to hear the caller at all I’d have to manage to switch the stereo to that input while driving, a mean feat since I don’t like to take my eyes from the road while the car is in motion to avoid running over babies or dying. Usually the end result was that people would call, I’d pick up, and they’d hear silence until they hung up.

It’s too bad the Soundfly BT doesn’t feature an option to have it not present itself to your phone as a hands-free system, because its A2DP streaming works a treat. For music streaming it’s almost perfect. It even comes with a remote that could conceivably control your connected device but will instead sit in the glove compartment unused, forever. It’s not that the Soundfly is a bad device, quite the opposite. I highly recommend it if your car doesn’t have a built in hands-free system that you like. Unfortunately I don’t think any similar device includes a feature to disable its hands-free system –this problem affects the entire product category. Maybe they’re all built around the same chipset and the chip is just incapable of advertising itself to the phone as anything but hands-free + A2DP, or maybe no manufacturer strays from using the reference design and bothers to let the user choose to disable one of its features?

A turnkey solution that I skipped due to cost and possibly-dumb philosophical reasons

At this point a normal person might consider buying a bluetooth car audio device that lacks a hands-free system and is known to turn on with the car and stream just fine. The TuneLink Auto (iOS version , Android version 4 ) looks to have been designed to fit this niche. But I have simple needs, and the TuneLink Auto seems to be positioned as a premium device with features and price to match. I don’t need a device controlled via a custom iOS or Android app 5, all I want is a cheap bluetooth device that turns on when power is supplied to it and supports the bluetooth A2DP profile and can stream music from my phone without issue, auto-reconnect would be a plus.

An unfortunately imperfect solution

I came across the EDUP EP-B3502 Wireless Car Bluetooth Music Receiver and bit the (very low-cost) bullet, for science. This device is almost great. Positives:
  • It doesn’t only charge its internal battery via its micro-USB port, but can run while so connected. That was the deal breaker for the similar BCK-08, a device with which I experimented a few years ago.
  • No hands-free profile – no more war with the car speakerphone!
  • It sounds pretty good, good enough at least. I never did a comparative test, but it seemed like it was maybe a small step down in audio quality from the Soundfly BT. It only costs about $13, and all the bluetooth audio devices are using lossy compression, so my expectations were met.
I used this device for a few weeks and at first it seemed all right. One notable negative is that the device does not power itself on when the car starts and power hits its micro-usb port. I’d have to hold down its large button for a couple of seconds at the start of every journey. The fact that this device didn’t clobber my car’s built-in hands-free system made this nit feel minor and worth tolerating, and I figured at some point I’d add some electronics to complete that circuit automatically. A bigger problem is that the thing would occasionally start overlaying beeps on the music. This always felt random, though my guess is that the device would decide that its battery (which I was not using) was low, or maybe it was trying to communicate some other unnecessary message to me. Whatever the reason, it’d interrupt my music with beeps seemingly at random, and this became a maddening thing. 6

Conclusion

Obviously this tale has to end with the abandonment of bluetooth streaming, a ton more research, the buying of parts, the setting up of development environments in a virtual machine, the compilation of custom firmwares, and a switch to the use of uncompressed 7 audio transmission over wifi to a hacked USB-powered router connected to a decent USB DAC. But that deserves its own post.

  1. If you’re lucky-enough to have such an aux input. ↩︎
  2. The “absurdly-deep friction-dependent smartphone and vaping device power outlet”? ↩︎
  3. Bluetooth A2DP, used for audio transmission, “supports optionally: MPEG-1, MPEG-2, MPEG-4, AAC, and ATRAC (shudder), and is extensible to support manufacturer-defined codecs, such as apt-X.” Wikipedia: Bluetooth profile, Advanced Audio Distribution Profile ↩︎
  4. A2DP is a cross-platform standard, and I can’t think of a good reason why whatever custom interface is used to communicate with the thing’s iOS and Android apps (bluetooth serial?) couldn’t be used for both iOS and Android. Why are there different versions of this device? ↩︎
  5. In fact, I see such a device as less valuable than a simpler device –it’s not unlikely that the device’s custom iOS app will not work years from now when our phones are running iOS v15 on 256-core CPUs. I’d rather the device have a non-proprietary control method not tied to custom software, such as a web interface, or some hardware buttons and an LCD. Why unnecessarily tie the future of a spend piece of hardware to software that could quickly become obsolete? ↩︎
  6. Honestly guys, it’s the 21st century, we shouldn’t have to decipher beeps or sequences of flashing LEDs any more than we should have to program computers with punch-cards. Instead of beeping, say what the problem is, in a language that is spoken in your target market. ↩︎
  7. well, non-lossy compression ↩︎

On Google Spreadsheets and Home Improvement

Friday, November 12th, 2010
7.1 Speaker Wire Run
201011121304

Amazon’s selling the “Ultimate Ears SuperFi 4” earbuds for $40 for 1 day (deal now dead)

Monday, September 20th, 2010
Edit 9/21/2010: This deal now dead. They’re now selling on Amazon for $74.99.

Ultimate Ears SuperFi 4
Because I’ve bought or browsed similar items in the past, Amazon.com just sent me an email to let me know that the “Deal of the Day” is the Ultimate Ears SuperFi 4 Noise Isolating Earphones, which they’re selling today for $39.99. The email says this is 69% off the list price. I don’t know what Amazon’s regular price for these is as they’ve already changed their price for today’s deal, but I do know that these same earbuds go for $121.10 at buy.com, and they have sold for around $80 new on eBay 1. So this really is a significant price drop for what is normally an expensive item. 2

The market has gotten pretty crowded since I first started using high-quality earbuds, and this particular pair is one of many I’ve never tried, but the reviews for the SuperFi 4’s look to be promising. For half price or less they may be a good choice if you’ve been considering a set of better earbuds than those which come with the iPod/iPhone/Zune/etc.

I like and recommend using earbuds over headphones when monitoring audio recording in a noisy environment, when watching or listening to a media player on a plane or train, or when listening to media in bed 3. I’ve had very good experiences with Shure earbuds and with the Future Sonics Atrios. My Shure e2c’s I bought very cheaply on an earlier deal, and I use them for running 4. The Atrios are part of my production kit, and I also use them when traveling. The fact that earbuds block a lot of surrounding noise, just as do earplugs, allows me to concentrate on listening at lower volume and without distraction. If you’ve got the need, these might be worth looking into while they’re discounted. 5

  1. My favorite way to determine the going price for an item is to do a search on eBay for completed auctions. ↩︎
  2. The last sale a search turns up for this item was back in July for $59.99. ↩︎
  3. I’ve slept with earbuds in and iPhone alarm on before when traveling or when sharing a room to avoid waking others. ↩︎
  4. Which I really need to get back to doing on a regular basis. ↩︎
  5. Or as Amazon says, “…while supplies last.” ↩︎

Adding a bluetooth audio input to my car stereo for <$15. Phase 1: research and experimentation.

Friday, July 9th, 2010
The stereo in my friend’s 2010 Prius 1 has a very useful feature: bluetooth audio input. As soon as he steps inside his car, his iPhone connects to the stereo wirelessly, and he can then play music from its library or using Pandora without connecting any cables.

The BCK-08 device.
I noticed that DealExtreme sells a bluetooth stereo music receiver for $12.99 2. This tiny, battery-operated device looks like an ugly cousin of an old iPod shuffle, sporting a big bluetooth symbol in the middle of its control pad. It’s designed to accept wireless transmissions from your iPhone, computer, or other device that supports bluetooth audio streaming, and then play that received audio out headphones connected to its jack. $12.99 falls well within my speculative hacking budget.

So I bought the device and have tested it out. When I plugged a cable between its headphone jack and my car’s audio input jack and streamed audio to it from my iPhone, it worked a treat. It shows up in the iPhone’s bluetooth menu as a device named,”BCK-08″.

There are a few problems. The device’s built-in battery is pathetic, and within an hour or two of use it begins to beep every few minutes to indicate that the battery needs a charge. I also think the audio quality decreases in direct proportion to the battery’s charge, but am not positive about that.

My goal is to take apart this device, wire it to be powered directly from my car, and leave it permanently connected to the car stereo’s auxiliary input jack.

I’ve found a few resources on the net that may be of help:

  1. I’m sure many other cars also have this feature. ↩︎
  2. The device’s full name on DealExtreme’s site is “Bluetooth 2.0 A2DP AVRCP Stereo Music Receiver and Handsfree (Black)” ↩︎
  3. I’ve been out of China for 3 years now and don’t feel like spending an hour fighting my way through the website with a dictionary in hand ↩︎
  4. Also from DealExtreme –how about that? ↩︎

Looong Steadicam Merlin + Canon T2i shot

Sunday, April 4th, 2010

Looong Steadicam Merlin + Canon T2i shot from ZachFine on Vimeo.

This is not the most exciting shot in the world to watch, but it was for me the most successful of my increasingly steady pairing of a Steadicam Merlin
with Canon EOS Rebel T2i
and Rode VideoMic
.

In order to stop down the kit lens‘s aperture enough to achieve anything approaching deep focus in the relatively dark location, I had to shoot at the camera’s 6400 ISO setting. My next big purchase will probably be a fast superwide zoom, maybe the Tokina 11-16mm f2.8
. My Canon 20mm f2.8
is just not wide enough –it’s the equivalent of a 36mm field of view on these APS-C sized sensors.

The steadicam was balanced so that it was just barely bottom heavy. About a 4-5 second drop (when the contraption is swiveled so that the camera and the counterweight are both level in front of me, it takes the camera about 5 seconds to float back upright). I enjoyed working with it so balanced.

The terrain was a little tricky. I had to weave around furniture, adults, and running little kids. It’s not the smoothest path I could have carved through the space, but I’m pleased with the improvisation. Around 45 seconds the camera tilted a bit, probably after I ran into something. I tried to tip it back.

The Rode Videomic is just directional enough to isolate bits of conversation in front of the camera. I can clearly hear my cousin Bruce explaining the intricacies of the game “Risk” and my Uncle Bob talking about a play he’d seen called “The Whipping Man
” as the camera passes each of them.

I applied a very temporary color correction with Final Cut Pro‘s 3-way color corrector filter, and applied very sophisticated titles and transitions, and exported to 1080p H264 using Compressor before uploading. Yay.

If it looks stuttery, try toggling “HD” to “off”.

How to use an iPod. A demonstration by Ari and Mirra.

Friday, April 2nd, 2010
1-3
I don’t hear anything. Is this thing on?
3
Ahhhhh. I hear something. Prog rock?


 


An unexpected musical treat: Letters vs. Numbers

Tuesday, August 4th, 2009
Img 0955
The other day I unexpectedly received a CD in the mail, from a sender whose name I didn’t recognize. The band: “Letters vs. Numbers”, album: “Bone Tired”. The back of the sleeve was a handwritten list of other recipients along with a printed request that the recipient rip the album to their computer, add their name and location to the list, and send it to someone else.

Always one to obediently follow directions, I ripped, signed, and sent. I also listened, and damned if it isn’t a great little album. Here’s the first track, “Forget Everything”, for your streaming or downloading pleasure 1 :

01 Forget Everything.mp3download mp3

I’d highly recommend that you receive this album by mail from a friend or an anonymous source. Failing that, the mysterious band 2 has a website, a myspace page 3, and the album is available at both the iTunes music store and the Amazon MP3 store.

  1. Hit the triangle button to play the track in your browser, or the download link to download the mp3 file ↩︎
  2. Their myspace page doesn’t list the names of band members, their number, or even a location. ↩︎
  3. The album can be listened to on the page in that icky myspace music player widget. ↩︎

Music: Soko, “I’ll Kill Her”. Awesomeness.

Wednesday, July 8th, 2009
Since I don’t live in Europe, I often miss out on the better music that hits the charts over there. I’m not saying they listen to better crap than USians in general because that generalization doesn’t 1 ring true (case in point: Crazy Frog didn’t go nuclear over here, thank god).

But every once in a while I hear something awesome from across the pond, and am surprised it got a massive amount of airtime elsewhere and is completely unknown here. The songs of Soko, a French singer/actress, fall into that category. Here’s her demented folk-rock hit “I’ll Kill Her”:

I ran into the song because it was the inspiration and soundtrack of this great motion graphics piece:

http://motionographer.com/2009/07/08/joerg-barton-ill-kill-her/

Worth a listen and a look IMO. Broaden your horizons, listen to songs about murderous impulses from across the pond 2.

  1. I nearly wrote “…that generalization doesn’t always ring true…”, meaning to imply that sometimes the generalization is true. But since a generalization that is sometimes true is by definition not a generalization at all, I left the original statement unqualified. To be clear, I think there’s plenty of great music all over the world, and plenty of crap. ↩︎
  2. After all my larger-world talk and attempts at drawing sweeping conclusions, I should point out that Soko has apparently moved to Los Angeles. So I guess that makes her yet another singer who lives in the US but is for now only well known and popular as a recording artist and performer in Europe, like David Hasselhoff or Steven Seagall. ↩︎

Turning an iPhone into an Apple ][

Tuesday, February 24th, 2009

200902241840.jpg
What I see when I power-up my iPhone. Below this should hopefully be an embedded QuickTime player set to play my Apple ][ disk drive ringtone.

A couple of weeks ago I met up with my friend Ben and we transferred a bunch of old apple II disks across a serial cable into a Linux box and saved them as disk images. Now I can once again run the programs I wrote in 3rd grade, in an emulator. While we transferred the disks, I was struck by the sound of the apple floppy drives and by the fantastic graphic design on the disk sleeves.

I snapped a photo of the disk sleeve and recorded the sounds of the disk drives with my iPhone. I took the disk drive noises and edited them into a ringtone, and set the disk sleeve image as my iPhone home screen background image.

The ringtone begins with the Apple II’s boot sequence and then transitions to a repeating sequence of disk head recalibration sounds. If you ever had an Apple II, you’ll recognize all of these noises. I installed the ringtone by double-clicking it (which loaded it into iTunes) and then syncing my iPhone to install the ringtone. It was then available in General Preferences > Sounds.

In case anyone else would also like to use this ringtone, I’ve added it to this post as an attachment. I have also attached the disk sleeve background image.

Download Apple ][ ringtone

Download Apple ][ disk sleeve image

Insanely good deal: Shure i2c in-ear monitors (earbuds) for $19.99

Tuesday, February 24th, 2009


“Shure I2C-MP Stereo Earphones / Headset (iPhone Compatible)” $19.99 at Amazon.com

Additional Note: These may be now be out of stock at Amazon. If so, the link will take you to the same item but likely at a different price, provided by a vendor other than Amazon. The different and likely higher price, and the lack of free shipping if your order hits $25, may be less enticing.

I bought a pair of these earbuds when they were marked down to $40 and have been using them for running. They’re very high-quality earbuds that are cheap enough that I don’t worry about destroying them with sweat or excessive wear and tear. These produce better audio than any earbud or headphone sold for under $50, probably better than any under $90 but I may have lost track of the market a little and am being conservative in my superlatives.

I wrote a little review of the i2c’s the last time they were on sale, gushing over what a great deal they were at double the current price. $19.99 is ridiculously low, I wonder if these have been discontinued? The previous review is worth a read if you’re considering this purchase.

If you do purchase these earbuds, I’d also recommend getting foam sleeves for them as it makes a huge difference in audio quality. The earbuds don’t ship with foam sleeves, but thin silicon sleeves that just hold the earbuds in the ear and provide negligible isolation from ambient sound. There’s also markedly more 1 bass when listening with foam sleeves.

Here are links to a few options for replacement foam sleeves:

  • The Shure Black Olive sleeves work well, though it takes a little work to fit them onto the earbuds. 2.
  • A slightly better sounding, but uglier and quicker to wear out set of foams are the Shure orange foam sleeves. They’d probably suck for running as they’d get saturated with sweat and are not easily washable.
  • The fancy ‘comply’ viscoelastic foam tips might be the most expensive and highest quality option, I’ve never tried them.

I’ve linked only to the large sizes of all of these foam sleeve options, as I figure the larger they attempt to expand the better seal they’ll make in the ear canal, leading to more sound isolation and better sound. But if you’re not sure you’ll find the large foams comfortable, they’re all also available in medium and small sizes if you poke around those web sites.

  1. but not excessive or muddy ↩︎
  2. The tubes in the black olive sleeves are slightly too narrow to fit, but can be momentarily stretched with a set of mini needlenose pliers just before installation on the earbuds. The tubes then shrink and hold the sleeves very tightly in place, which I think is a positive thing ↩︎