The 10,062
Sunday, August 26th, 2007- If you don’t know what this post means, what a Genesis is, etc, don’t worry. This post is just a brief bit of gloating. I’ll cover some of the details later. ↩︎
Just tell us what iPod model you want to protect and we provide a gutted and hinged Zune with our custom molded iPod casing adapter. We also include a custom cable from the Zune’s controls (see FAQ) and audio output jack that you simply plug into your iPod. No iPod modifications are necessary.
It’s a bit of a cheap shot –the Zune didn’t look 1 all that bad 2– but that page is pretty damned funny. Do click through and attempt to buy one (don’t worry, it’s not really for sale, but the ordering page is amusing).
Apple released their web browser, Safari, for Windows a couple of days ago, and since then it has been downloaded over a million times. I’d love to know why all those people downloaded it.
Was the reason:
Speaking for myself, I downloaded it out of curiosity, and ran it for a few minutes on Chinese Windows XP running under Parallels Desktop (running an Apple app inside of Windows on a Mac – kind of like making turducken out of fruit and building materials). It seemed fine for browsing, I remember feeling that it looked better typography-wise than IE or Firefox on Windows, but I didn’t quantify that feeling with any testing.
A million downloads in two days is a big number, I’d love to know the reason why Jane Doe Windows user would download Safari rather than or in addition to Firefox or IE7. I’d also love to know why Apple released Safari for Windows –does Apple feel that releasing a browser for Windows with a bit of a Mac look and feel will attract more people to switch over to OS X?
A Chinese mac developer named Feng Huajun has made a Chinese pinyin input method for the mac called “Fun Input Toy” (henceforth FiT). According to a blog post I read on the www, it is a big improvement on the standard Mac input method. I don’t know if my Chinese is at the level where I can really tell the difference, but I tried FiT out and it seemed to me that it predicted my input better than the ITABC method that ships with OS X, and it also allowed me to type full sentences at a time.
Those of you who have never tried to type a non-phonetic language into your computer might find that last paragraph to be unintelligible. The basic idea is that, in order to enter Chinese ideographs (characters) from a keyboard that doesn’t have tens of thousands of keys, you instead type in the pronunciation of each character. As you type the sounds of the words, the computer checks these against a database and starts replacing the syllables with its best guess at the appropriate character. A good input method will notice combinations of syllables that make up common words and phrases, and will also remember words you use most frequently and will present those to you first when you are asked to select from a long list of identical sounding words that match what you’ve typed. It all works better than you might think.
For example, to type this phrase that my sister knows well (her standard phrase when she worked at a Chinese hospital for a few weeks), I switch to the FiT input method and start typing the sounds using the pinyin romanization system:

Notice that FiT has guessed each character or phrase as I’ve gone along. If I hit the ‘1’ key, it’ll convert the text I’ve entered to this string of Chinese text “你的小儿是很漂亮”. The other options are there in case when I began typing I really meant to enter one of the other characters that sound like “ni”. If I choose say character #6, FiT will just replace the first character of my text with that choice and will go on to try and match the rest of the sentence:

That’s much more like the experience of using OS X’s built-in ITABC input method, which requires you to choose character or phrase by phrase. It’s very nice that FiT lets you type a lot more, and shows you the options as you type. So if you use a Mac, and enter Chinese, you would do well to try the free FiT input method. Kudos to Feng Huajun for releasing it. It appears to be superior to the input method that came on your machine by default.
Net connections are not good from Beijing. How not good? So not good that whenever I try to watch any streaming media clip, such as anything on youtube, the New York Times, Salon.com’s Video Dog, the embedded video clips on Robert Scoble’s blog, etc; On any of these I can only see a few seconds of video at a time with long stretches of still frames while reading text that says “Buffering 6%”, “Buffering 11%”, “Buffering 14%”, etc.
Salon.com’s flash-based media player is the worst of the lot. With many streaming media players, if I get tired of watching the video in 2 second bursts, I can just walk away and read the latest Harry Potter novel, then return, rewind the clip, and watch the now-fully-buffered clip in its entirety. The player for Salon.com’s video dog, if left alone for a bit, apparently erases its buffer and jumps back to the beginning of the clip. Thus, unless I’m prepared to sit there and monitor the buffering of the clip and hit the rewind and play buttons during the window of opportunity, I do not get to see the clip at all.
Speaking of streaming media, “goodbye and good luck” to Calvert DeForest (AKA Larry “Bud” Melman), we hardly knew ye
The existence of this clip illustrates the value of the common archive that occurs when ordinary people are given the ability to record and preserve media, hooray for VHS.
I believe there are reasons to provide streaming media, which I’ll explain below, but any instance of streaming media on a web page should always be accompanied by a link that users can click to download the video as a file.
I wrote to Salon.com a year ago, asking if they would please make their video files available for download, not just as streams. They responded that this was not possible because the videos contain bits of copyrighted media. This is an unnecessary and particularly gutless bit of rationalization. Salon.com is a publication and can easily justify its redistribution of these excerpts of tv shows as commentary, protected as “fair use” under U.S. copyright law. Their stance is both gutless and bizarre –in what way is providing media on which you do not own the copyright any better when provided as a stream rather than a file? I guess we’ll find out for sure if YouTube tries the “but we only provide streaming media” defense in the billion dollar Viacom vs. YouTube lawsuit.
Ranting aside, I admit there is one very good reason to use streaming media on a site. With a good net conection, playback of streaming media starts instantly and requires no download. Not only does playback of streaming media begin just after the user clicks the media, but the better streaming servers (QuickTime, Windows Media) can adjust the bandwidth of the video to match the user’s net speed. It is of course, also possible for playback of certain kinds of downloaded files to begin immediately (QuickTime files), but not with the same level of bandwidth control.
But another reason to use streaming media is dumb and evil. The logic probably goes something like this
If I, the company hosting the video, provide a file to users as a stream and not as a download, then the user can’t keep the file and do nefarious things with it. Thus I keep the level of control I desperately need over the media and its distribution.
Dumb dumb dumb. This begins with the assumption that people who plan to watch the video you provide have criminal intentions that can be thwarted by not providing them with an actual video file. It’s that kind of lack of trust that leads to unnecessary technological stumbling blocks that just make things more difficult for ordinary non-criminal users. And the stumbling blocks are annoying rather than effective –the desired level of control over a stream is barely possible (for the moment it’s possible to surreptitiously download video files from YouTube and some other streaming flash sites, and I am grateful, because otherwise I would never be able to watch these videos).
So while it’s great that users are putting more and more video online, it is unfortunate that much of this video is available only as streaming media, which us reasonably law abiding users can’t put on an ipod, and can only watch in excruciatingly low quality (due to streaming servers’ bandwidth control features) on sub-amazing net connections if at all.
On the bright side, due to the popularity of the iPod and other mp4 video devices (I’m trying to not be a total Apple partisan here), plus the fact that Apple put podcasting features and a free and easy to use podcast directory into their ubiquitous iTunes software (gotta give ’em huge props for that), downloadable video files are becoming much more common. I found a video podcast of the aforementioned Scoble show in the iTunes Music Store’s podcast directory. These are downloadable mp4 versions of the same video clips I could not watch as inline streaming flash video on the Scobleizer blog. The New York Times also puts many of its video clips online in a series of video podcasts, though they inexplicably miss the ones I’d actually like to watch, like the video about Chinese adoptee Cece Nealon-Shapiro’s bat mitzvah, which is only available as a stream.
Everything I’ve said above also applies to audio streams. The Recidivism blog republished NPR’s great Fresh Air interview with Sacha Baron Cohen as an mp3 file. Previously it was available only from NPR’s site as a stream and as that blogger says “Streams are completely useless when I’m trying to use my device (acrylic push-button model) in the car”. A comment on that blog post mentions that NPR has taken the audio stream down, so the existence of this user-hosted mp3 file may be the only way to hear the interview. This is a great example of two reasons why such files should be available for download rather than just as streams: users should be able to listen to such audio clips on the device of their choosing, and interesting files can have more staying power if they are not only hosted as streams that might be taken down at any moment. Imagine the photographic evidence of history that would be lost if all daguerrotypes had only been available for viewing in one building, which then burned to the ground.

If you ever find yourself using bittorrent technology to download files, and you run OS X, you would do well to check out the great new bittorrent client Xtorrent. It’s still in beta, it’s commercial, but it’s the best I’ve ever used on any platform.
It allows you to search a set of preset and customizable torrent search sites from a unified search field, and it presents results as both a simple unified list of results with download buttons and also as a series of embedded web pages in tabs. It supports torrentcast subscriptions, allows you to (try to) open partially downloaded files in your choice of application from a contextual menu, bandwidth limits, and remains responsive when downloading multiple torrents. A great UI completes the package.
Definitely worth a look.
I’ve been using Apple’s mail application for a while, and I like it, but it has been getting slower and slower over time. It turns out that the culprit, according to comments on the Hawk Wings blog, is that the “envelope” sqlite database that Mail.app uses can become larger than necessary, full of empty space left behind when objects have been dropped, and a simple command executed in the terminal reorganizes the data structures. The process (which involves the sqlite command “vacuum”) is analogous to defragmenting a disk.
Following the directions on that web site, I quit the Mail application. I then opened Terminal and ran the following optional command so that I could see the size of Mail’s Envelope database before and after the cleanup:
% ls -lah ~/Library/Mail/Envelope\ Index
-rw-r--r-- 1 zach zach 42M Mar 6 00:55 /Users/zach/Library/Mail/Envelope Index
I then ran the actual cleanup command:
% sqlite3 ~/Library/Mail/Envelope\ Index vacuum index;
That took about a minute. I then again checked the size of the Envelope Index:
% ls -lah ~/Library/Mail/Envelope\ Index
-rw-r--r-- 1 zach zach 25M Mar 6 01:07 /Users/zach/Library/Mail/Envelope Index
Hot damn! The database dropped in size from 42Mb down to 25Mb. I ran Mail, and it popped up near instantaneously. Wouldn’t you know, it is now lightning fast to open folders full of thousands of messages. Before I “vacuumed” the Envelope index, such a folder might have taken upwards of 10 seconds to open.
If you’re running OS X Tiger and have been using Apple’s Mail application, do yourself a favor and try running the commands to “vacuum” Mail’s Envelope Index. If Mail.app has been slow, you may be shocked by the increase in speed. At the very least, you’ll recover a bit of disk space.
You may have heard that the concept of intellectual property hasn’t developed here in China to the same point that it has reached in the West. “Counterfeit”, “pirate”, or otherwise infringing products are sold very openly. That is one side of the coin. The flipside is that the understanding of branding and brand marketing is a nascent field here.
So it was with great interest that I noticed an Apple store in a small town near Shanghai. Stores selling Apple computers in China never seem to have gotten the memo –they are not nearly as appealing as the Apple stores in the U.S., possibly because they are all independent resellers and are not run by Apple itself. In contrast, this store was doing everything right.
The store had a huge apple logo over the entrance, a nice layout, and the products all prominently displayed the apple logo. Posters on the walls showed the logo alongside athletes (a ping pong or badminton champ) endorsing the product, and the whole place was very clean and bright. But the most amazing thing about this store was that despite its appearance it was not an Apple store. Instead it was a store for “Golden Appleâ„¢” brand athletic shoes, obviously it’s simply a coincidence that their logo and store look very much like those of a famous company headquartered in Cupertino.
Since I needed a pair of shoes, and I have been making a habit of buying ostentatiously infringing products (preferably with misspelled brand names) whenever possible, I purchased a pair. The apple logo on the insole of the shoe even had a piece of clear plastic over it to protect it during shipping –that’s the kind of care taken to present one’s logo in a positive light that I expect to see from a company like the U.S.’s Apple Inc.
I played dumb and asked the employees if they also sold computers, and they told me “oh no, that is an American company. We are a Chinese company and do not sell computers.” They added “our logo is different, it has a bite”, perhaps with that statement betraying that they actually do understand intellectual property issues related to trademarks. They seemed so sincere they almost had me convinced, but their logo really is practically identical to Apple Inc’s logo.
On the plus side, If Apple Inc ever decides to sell shoes in China, I know just the company they should partner with. “Golden Apple” is perfect –they understand branding and customer experience better than most Chinese stores, and already have experience selling Apple branded products. They’d just need a few training sessions to get up to speed on intellectual property issues.
I love my Apple –excuse me, Golden Apple shoes.
We’ve all waited and waited like hungry beavers for the iPhone announcement. Now that the exhilarating presentation is over, everything else just feels…anticlimactic. How can one feel excitement at anything for the rest of the day, or the week –by noting how the iPhone differs from perfection, that’s how. If this hasn’t already become a popular pastime, it will soon. And the iPhone, amazing as it looks, and though it might seem insanely great, does have many deficiencies that can be named and counted. Follow along and see how much better you feel with each bullet point, listed in order of importance.
Uh oh, I just watched the flash animation on Apple’s site of the iPhone’s music interface. Amazing. What a perfect tactile interface, and the use of coverflow is outstanding. And since the iPhone really does run OS X, emacs vm-mode might be a possibility. Unfortunately, despite having worked up a list of the product’s many real and imaginary flaws, I think the iPhone announcement may well kill my enthusiasm for any other not-yet-released-product-announcement this week.
The “kill” button is just one of the iPhone‘s most innovative new features.A while back, when rumors of an Apple cell phone began circulating, I only allowed myself low expectations. Given how uninteresting the Motorola Rokr was (100 song limit?!), and how crazy the rumors sounded, I figured this was a reasonable move. There were signs of something good in the offing –Apple’s late-2005 patent filing for a touch-screen interface that displayed a “virtual scroll wheel” was a dead giveaway that this technology would be in future Apple handheld devices, but other details were less easy to guess, and the guesses rampant on the net sounded outlandish. I assumed that other rumors to be just rumors, especially the one which stated that the phone would be a full-on smartphone that runs a version of OS X, or that it would have WiFi networking built in. What pie-in-the-sky thinking. I expected only a fairly simple but nice phone with a touch-screen interface paired with an iPod nano, basically a phone with 8Gb of music on board. Maybe smartphone features would come in a later edition. I didn’t expect WiFi to ever be included.
There were reasons for my skepticism about WiFI. Cell phone companies do not love everything about smartphones, specifically they don’t like smartphones that they can’t control, that might not allow them to take a cut of everything. Rumor has it that the Rokr couldn’t buy songs from iTunes because the carriers wouldn’t allow it unless the price per song was jacked up and they could get a huge cut. It is rumored that similar pressure from carriers is the reason the Palm Treos lack WiFi. Palm actually makes a SD-card WiFi adapter for their PDAs, but for some reason never released a driver to make this device work in their Treo smartphones. The carriers control the cell phone market. As a cell phone manufacturer you’re screwed if Sprint, for example, says they won’t carry your smartphone in their stores if you allow the phone to access WiFi networks, because they worry that consumers will install Skype or other voice-over-IP software (VOIP) and use it over wireless networks rather than paying for minutes. Some Windows Mobile phones work with WiFi, maybe Microsoft had enough clout to push that past the carriers, I’m really not sure how that happened.
I was quite wrong. The Apple iPhone really is a step up from the Newton MP2000, and has a lower price.In any case, I was wrong to lower my expectations for Apple’s iPhone, because the cell phone Apple has announced sounds terrific. Here’s a rundown of my thoughts on the features of the announced device:
I’m impressed. If it’s easy to develop software for this phone, and Chinese language support is forthcoming, and the touchscreen isn’t a pain, and I feel like I can afford one, and my Treo 650 falls down a well, I’ll consider one of these.