Microsoft blogger criticizes the hand that feeds over Chinese censorship capitulation

Blogging dissident views from within China can be tough. For starters, the local authorities will not be happy with you, and at a minimum your blog might well be taken down. If your site is on a server outside China, it will be rendered inaccessible to users inside the Great Firewall of China (for example, I was there just last week and noticed that all blogspot.com pages were mysteriously non-responsive from within the firewall).

But the local government isn’t necessarily the only one imposing restrictions on speech. It appears that some US companies are willing to go one step further to help restrict information flowing into China — Microsoft technical evangelist and blogger Robert Scoble, on his blog, has recently excoriated the hand that feeds him in a post entitled Microsoft takes down Chinese blogger (my opinions on that). It’s worth a read.

I think Scoble is absolutely right to be upset and to speak his mind, and yet the situation is also quite complex. Companies do have good reason to go along with the whims of governments. Besides the profit motive, the classic explanation given is that International companies do need to follow the local laws of the countries in which they operate, and China does have some “vaguely worded subversion laws on the books”. This is the reason given by Yahoo for why it gave the Chinese government access to the email account of a Chinese journalist who used his Yahoo account to send an internal Communist Party message (ironically a message advising the press on what to and not to say when reporting on the “15th Anniversary of the June 4th incident”) to foreigners. That man was arrested and sentenced to 10 years in prison for “leaking top state secrets”.

But when should companies follow local laws and when should they reject them, and what if rejecting the local law would put employees who live in the country in question at risk? Scoble touches briefly on these issues in a followup post.

My thoughts on this at the moment are that

  • Companies need to have very clear policies on how best to comply with local law enforcement in place, in advance of the development of such situations
  • There needs to be a public dialogue about the ethical and moral merits of these policies
  • Users in affected countries need to be made aware of these policies when they sign up for a company’s services
  • I am uncomfortable with the idea that companies from the “…land of the Free and the home of the brave.” are assisting another country in the censoring of political discourse.
  • the argument that companies operating internationally need to follow local laws is much more persuasive than arguments that value free markets and the profit motive above free speech — despite the fact that their actions have directly resulted in imprisonments of individuals, what Yahoo and Microsoft have done in these two cases seems much more defensible to me than the efforts Microsoft, Cisco, and other U.S. companies have contributed toward the building of China’s Great Firewall. How much have these companies earned building the firewall and to what end?

I wonder if one day we’ll see Chinese companies operating in the U.S. facing criticism in their home country for going along with requests made of them by the U.S. government that seem ethically or morally wrong to Chinese people.

3 Responses to 'Microsoft blogger criticizes the hand that feeds over Chinese censorship capitulation'

  1. Jim Says:

    Very interesting posting. I respectfully disagree that the argument that companies operating internationally need to follow local laws can hold up where the Yahoo! incident is concerned. That might be okay for companies that are selling toothbrushes or tables in China, but Yahoo’s service is directly linked to a fundamental human right. So in order to comply with local laws, they must perform a human rights abuse. And if you break the argument down, the basic purpose of the argument that companies coperating internationally IS to maintain profits. It would be very expensive for Yahoo! to perform legal reviews on every request they get, and weigh them against international law. The “local law” disclaimer is a convenient and cheap way to circumvent those expenses.

  2. zach Says:

    Thanks for the great comment Jim. If it sounded like I was justifying Yahoo’s actions, I respectfully disagree with my own post as well.

    I do think there is a case to be made for corporations to follow local laws, and it can be very patronizing to tell a country “we’ll do business in your country but we don’t like your laws and won’t follow them”, but a line has to be drawn somewhere. Defining that line by determining a set of fundamental human rights is a good start.

    When you start talking about international law, I start thinking about treaties. I wonder if China has signed any treaties that define what ‘fundamental human rights’ they support (‘no’ seems a good bet). This all reminds me of extradition treaties (which China hasn’t been able to negotiate with many countries). If governments can refuse to send corrupt Chinese officials back to China to face prosecution because they disagree with the punishment that will be meted out, can international corporations (many of which are as large and influential as countries) refuse to turn people in to foreign governments if they disagree over the severity of punishment or even on whether or not a crime has been committed?

  3. zach Says:

    BTW, good luck with your site. It’s important that Yahoo and other companies know that U.S. citizens aren’t happy with companies that aid in the repression of political speech. We have leverage and it’s called dollars.

    My impression is that U.S. companies could have a very positive effect in China and really help the Chinese people by using their influence with the CCP, but it looks like it will take some pressure from the U.S. public on those companies to convince them. The more criticism these companies face here, the more incentive (and bargaining power) they will have to push back when the CCP makes demands of them, and then the more incentive the CCP will have to be accomodating to its citizenry in order to preserve the influx of foreign capital. It would be nice if all corporations and governments put morals first and business second, but it just doesn’t seem to work that way.

    Here’s a thought, if Yahoo would avoid storing tracking info for users on servers in China, they’d have nothing stored locally to give the local officials. Requests to access data stored on servers in the U.S. would require that China sign the “data extradition treaty of 2006” first, and that agreement could include that “no data will be extradited for use in prosecuting people for political speech” (needs better wording, but you get the idea). This would protect yahoo from having to put its Chinese employees in peril, because they would not be the ones refusing to turn over data and wouldn’t even have access to the data.

Leave a Reply