Politics

China From the Inside

Thursday, January 11th, 2007

I would love to see this new 4-hour documentary about China made for Granada-KQED-PBS-BBC entitled China From the Inside.

From the article:

The footage is vast. Cameras traveled to Tibet; Xinjiang, home to many Muslims; the Kazakhstan border; the Gobi Desert; and the Yangtze River. There are interviews with women activists trying to instill self-confidence among rural women (to try to help stave off a high suicide rate); a National People’s Congress delegate comparing communism with U.S. democracy; a Catholic priest practicing religion in an atheist country; and residents who’ve been displaced by the gargantuan construction of the Three Gorges Dam.
…an environmental activist talks about the polluted Huai River, its cancer-inducing contaminants ravaging the lives of villagers whose photos he displays. In the segment about women, a factory worker in Guangdong Province talking about her day-to-day life: Working the assembly line and prohibited from talking between 6:08 a.m. and 6:08 p.m.

It’s no surprise that the Chinese government was a little concerned about the making of this documentary, but it sounds as though the government minders assigned to this project deserve much respect for making excuses and leaving the set when sensitive topics were being covered. The fact that the documentary’s director had previously made a 4-part documentary entitled “Hell in the Pacific” about the Nanjing massacre by the Japanese probably helped him get reasonably free access to cover sensitive locations, people, and topics.

Thanks to <shamus> for the link.

A simple request for whoever maintains China’s internet connection to the outer world

Tuesday, December 26th, 2006

Could whoever was updating the great firewall of China about 24 hours ago please double-check your work? The entire internet outside of China, or at least the portion of the net that includes all web traffic (port 80), has been completely inaccessible for the past day. Websites originating outside of China take about 10 minutes to load, if at all. I know you need to occasionally update the great firewall in order to better block any websites that contain unhealthy thoughts or statements critical of the Chinese government that might lead to instability, yadda yadda yadda, but when updating the firewall’s rules it’s important to take care that you not block simply everything. Argh.

Update: It would appear that the net in China is down due to an earthquake in Taiwan. I still blame the firewall, partly because it’s annoying and I like to blame it for things, mostly because if it weren’t for this country’s need to filter the net they’d have more than one point of connection to the outside world –we could all get to yahoo.com just as easily through Russia or Japan as Taiwan if such connections existed. In any case, I hope all the people in Taiwan are OK, I’d know more about this quake if I could get to an English language news website.

Google poised and ready to offer mail service in China

Thursday, August 3rd, 2006

a screen capture of a portion of the Gmail China login page
Citing political and ethical considerations, Google hasn’t yet launched its free email service, Gmail, in China. But why is this Gmail China login screen online?


Google, in order to comply with Chinese government policy, censors the search results it displays to users who access its www.google.com.cn site (that ‘cn’ at the end of the name indicates a Chinese website). This was big news a little while back, as it marked the moment that the company which proudly cites “Do No Evil” as one of its guiding principles made compromises for the sake of reach and profit that many outside China found distasteful. Google is in good company, Microsoft’s MSN Spaces blocks Chinese users from posting articles that include words like “democracy” and “freedom”, Skype’s text chat here censors certain words, and Yahoo has gone even further in its compliance with Chinese government censorship policies –I’ll return to this topic in a bit. All of these companies justify their actions by saying that they must comply with local regulations when they operate in other countries.Users in China who can read English (such as myself) can still search the web using the good ‘ol www.google.com URL, and get uncensored search results. It’s a pyrrhic victory — you can see the unfiltered results but the sites are generally blocked by the Great Firewall of China, so it feels as if Google is just returning many dead links. For an amusing visual look at how the censorship affects Google image results, see this great side-by-side comparison of a politically sensitive google image search.

Back when Google’s compliance with the Chinese government was a big news item, articles often contained statements such as the following:

Neither Google’s e-mail nor blogging services will be offered in China because the company doesn’t want to risk being ordered by the government to turn over anyone’s personal information.

This is because any company that plants its servers on Chinese soil will place information on those servers within reach of the Chinese government. If Google were to store user’s personal information on servers within China, the Chinese government could request for this information, and Google would have to comply or risk the consequences.

Yahoo found itself in exactly such a sticky situation last year. The Chinese government decided that information posted to the web by a user with an anonymous Yahoo email address was a state secret and asked Yahoo’s Hong Kong office to provide them with the user’s personal information. Yahoo complied, and former Yahoo user Shi Tao was sentenced to 10 years in prison. News of Yahoo’s disclosure of the anonymous user’s identity, and a recently discovered case of another unmasked Yahoo user who received an 8 year prison term for discussing pro-democracy issues in a web forum, has caused some people in Western countries to criticize, boycott, and perhaps even advocate divesting from Yahoo and other U.S. internet firms operating in China.

Which brings us back to Google and this post’s title. Google may not be ready yet, politically, to roll-out their anonymous gmail service to Chinese users, but they do appear to have some Gmail China functionality online, ready and waiting for the green light. I know this because out of simple curiousity I added a “.cn” to the “gmail.com” URL in my browser, and lo and behold I reached this Gmail China login screen. Attempts to login fail with a “can’t find the server at mail.google.com.cn” error. This suggests that the login screen is programmed to eventually bring registered users to their mail on servers in China.

I wonder when Gmail China will launch and what criteria Google, the “Don’t Be Evil” company, will use to decide when the time is right.

What is Spiritual Pollution?

Wednesday, August 2nd, 2006
A panorama of a polluted day in SihuiThis is ordinary 污染 (pollution, pronounced “wūrăn”). Cough cough. Not to be confused with 精神污染 (spiritual pollution, pronounced “jīngshenwūrăn”). 精神污染 is a mental and moral affliction, spread by bourgeois values and Western media.
A panorama of a clear day in SihuiAh that’s better, the wind has blown all that blasted 污染 away. Now it’s Someone else’s problem. To be fair, the view has looked a lot more like this lately, perhaps the local power plant has been offline. I have heard that the Beijing government is taking air quality seriously these days, and promises a “Green Beijing” in time for the 2008 Olympics. Regardless, plenty of invisible 精神污染 undoubtedly remains. Click either photo to view larger versions.

In a tangentially apropos comment to my Hao Wu post Angus asks “I really enjoy your blog but why do you call it Spiritual Pollution?”

The answer is that the title of the blog is actually In Beijing, which I plan to keep in place. But below the title is space for an amusing or evocative phrase, a subtitle. At the moment, that subtitle is Spiritual Pollution. I love this phrase, it is so colorful, and springs from such a grand utopian vision.

I ran across this great little phrase when I was reading about the Chinese novelist Mian Mian. She wrote a very popular book entitled Candy which was banned by Chinese censors. The barely-fictional book includes both sex and heroin abuse, and I guess the censors weren’t too keen on either topic. Most articles about her mention that authorities or censors have called Mian “a poster child for spiritual pollution.” You can see Mian Mian read some excerpts from Candy on the internet, courtesy of U.S. Public Broadcasting.

I’m embarrassingly ignorant of Chinese history, so it is fun to learn so much about of it by merely investigating one catchy little phrase. The phrase spiritual pollution did not originate with Mian Mian, nor is she the first Chinese novelist accused of spreading spiritual pollution.

Spiritual Pollution‘s heyday was back in the early 80s. Deng Xiaoping, a Chinese leader generally described as a reformer, had opened China economically, but was very wary of Western cultural influences. He gave a speech calling for a campaign against spiritual pollution (精神污染 – jīngshenwūrăn) an umbrella phrase used to categorize Western influences, bourgeois attitudes, and anything considered vulgar or anti-party. Painter and author Ma Jian was interrogated by China’s Public Security Bureau and faced arrest on the charge of spiritual pollution after neighbors reported his “bourgeois” activities to the police (activities such as reading xeroxed underground magazines and chatting with dissident friends late at night). Ma fled Beijing and travelled through remote areas of China for 3 years under pseudonyms. He wrote a book about his 3 year journey entitled Red Dust: A Path Through China. The book was translated into English, and I’m now a couple of enjoyable chapters into it.

Prosecutions on the charge of Spiritual Pollution seem to be much less in vogue these days than they were back in ’83. China has opened up culturally to the point where kids here happily flaunt NBA basketball jerseys and watch the latest US blockbusters on readily available pirate DVDs without worried neighbors turning them in to the police. But though the phrase may have lost its (punitive) bite, the comments from censors about Mian Mian show that it is not dead.

Here’s a bit more history on the phrase. According to an article entited China; Rectification and Reform:

…
A campaign against “spiritual pollution” was initiated by a speech given at the Second Plenum by Deng Xiaoping (see Policy Toward Intellectuals , ch. 4). The campaign targeted “decadent, moribund ideas of the bourgeoisie” that questioned the suitability of the socialist system or the legitimacy of the party’s leading role. It also sought to establish a basis for ideological continuity between the emerging younger generation and the older, civil-war-era veterans. Conservative Political Bureau members attempted to use the campaign to rectify what they considered decadent behavior and corrosive liberal thought. Following this example, some lower-level party cadres began to exhibit behavior similar to that of the mass campaigns of the Cultural Revolution. Young men and women with long hair or Western-style clothing were subjected to ridicule and abuse. Peasants who had prospered were accused of selfishness; in response, some ceased to participate in rural reform. Intellectuals were again under suspicion, and party and government cadres adopted a “wait-and-see” attitude to avoid making political errors.
…

I hope this answers your question.

Hao Wu is free!

Friday, July 14th, 2006

Free Hao Wu I was planning to collect and post my thoughts on the disappearance of Chinese filmmaker and blogger Hao Wu, but I’m happy to report that he has reappeared before my slow thought processes could finish. Hao Wu, a Chinese-born U.S. permanent resident, was working on a documentary film about an underground Christian Church in China when he was “detained” by police on February 22, 2006. Hao was an active blogger and journalist, and it is unknown whether he was detained for these activities or for filmmaking. He was never charged with a crime and was not allowed to meet with an attorney. His case received a lot of attention the world over, and is documented at the Free Hao Wu website. On my recent trip to Minnesota, I was very happy to see his face on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. Thankfully, Hao Wu has been released after almost five months in prison and is now resting with his family in Beijing. I am glad, and wish them all well. He sounds like a cool guy, and I hope to see his film one day.

There are still many people who have been detained or imprisoned in China for exercising what many consider to be a fundamental human right, freedom of speech. I hope that the Chinese legal system will further develop to offer Chinese people these and other rights they are supposed to be granted in the Constitution of the People’s Republic of China, such as the freedom of speech granted them in article 35, freedom of religious belief (article 36), freedom from unlawful detention (article 37), etc etc.

That was Beijing and Shanghai

Wednesday, March 29th, 2006

The creator of the English language magazines That’s Shanghai and That’s Beijing, both very good sources of information and entertainment for expats living in those cities, has apparently had control of the magazines wrested from him and is now airing his gripes in a Prospect magazine article entitled That’s China. The tagline:

After seven years building up a magazine empire in China, I had it stolen by the state.

Ouch. That sucks.

The article includes some great little stories about all the legal and procedural hurdles Mark and the magazine staff faced in order to put out their magazine. It is worth a read.

a few more related links:

meta-absurd israeli anti-semitic cartoon contest

Wednesday, February 15th, 2006

Wow, this is a crazy one. First (some) Muslims the world over get (extremely) riled up about a ‘cartoons of Mohammed’ contest in Denmark and the republication of the cartoons in papers across Europe, and then an Iranian paper announces that it’s running a ‘best anti-semitic cartoon’ contest in retaliation, and now an Israeli paper has proudly boasted that Israelis will be able to make the best anti-semitic cartoons, and has launched a new contest, the Israeli Anti-Semitic Cartoon Contest.

No joke. Or lots of jokes. See it how you like.

U.S. pyramid scheme scams hit Botswana

Friday, January 20th, 2006

We’ve all received and been annoyed or amused by the ubiquitous Nigerian scam emails. But it appears that deceptive business practices don’t just travel in one direction. People in Botswana are getting annoyed with an “American scam” that has hit their turf.

There’s less irony to be had here than meets the eye. Botswana and Nigeria are pretty distant from one another in many ways. Out of all the countries in Africa, Nigeria was rated most corrupt and Botswana the least (according to Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index 2004). For all I know, Botswana’s citizens get pummelled by Nigerian scam emails too.

maybe avian flu can be mild

Wednesday, January 11th, 2006

According to Elizabeth Rosenthal of the International Herald Tribune, Doctors in Turkey are closely monitoring a pair of brothers who “have tested positive for the H5N1 virus after contact with sick birds, neither has any symptoms of the frequently deadly disease.” Here’s a key quote:

These cases have raised the possibility that human bird flu is not as deadly as has been thought, and that there may be many mild cases that have gone unreported.

Maybe I wasn’t too far off when I posted some doubts about the purported mortality rate of the avian flu. I’d said:

My presumption is that the “50% mortality rate” may be wrong because it’s not unlikely that there are many unconfirmed — it may be likely that the vast, vast majority of people who come down with the avian flu think they just have a bad case of the normal flu and don’t die and don’t go to the hospital and are hence, not confirmed cases.

Well, it’s a nice thought. I do hope the virus is less of a killer than expected. It’d be nice to live to see the Beijing Olympics.

the chinese cars are coming

Monday, January 9th, 2006

Will your next car be made in China? Actually, your current car may already be made in China, at least in part. Volkswagen and GM have plants in Shanghai, and make most of the cars that I saw on the streets of that city (the most common being the VW Santana, since almost all taxis were driving that model). Similarly, a large percentage of cars on the streets of Beijing came from that city’s Hyundai plant. I think these plants are probably producing cars to be sold to the huge Chinese market, but it would not surprise me if they’re also making parts for cars sold in the U.S. and other countries around the world.

But where are the Chinese car companies? Every once in a while I’d see a generic-looking Chinese car or van driving around –a striking achievement in this day and age when every fracking sedan looks like a slight variation on the Toyota Camry. These cars were well camouflaged in the sea of GMs, Hyundais, and VWs, but they were there. How long will it be before cars from these Chinese auto manufacturers begin to invade the home turf of U.S. automakers? According to this article, privately-owned Chinese automaker Geely (why do they have to pop-up not one but two ads! do they want people to avoid their site?) plans to sell cars in the U.S. in 2008, and State-owned Chery (another pop-up, argh) in 2007.

Perhaps one day, GMs, Buicks, and Fords, will only sell overseas, and China, Japan, and Korea will own the U.S. market.

As an aside, it’s hardly appropriate to speak of Chinese companies without at least making mention of the possibility of copyright, patent, and trademark infringements. Signing the WTO made China the place for international investment, but it also means that China is supposed to start protecting intellectual property the way everyone else does. At last count, GM was suing Chery for copying the design of the Spark, Honda was suing Shuanghuan Automobile for copying the design of the CR-V, and Toyota recently lost a trademark lawsuit against Geely. As reported here.