Filmmaking

An error message I’d love to see improved in Snow Leopard

Tuesday, April 7th, 2009
OS X's "disk is in use" error dialog

Oh how I hate the above error message. It’s not that it’s completely uninformative, but it’s a perfect case of “so close but yet so far”…

Anyone who uses as many external disks on a Mac as I do is apt to occasionally have trouble properly unmounting and ejecting those disks 1. Before unmounting a disk, it’s necessary to stop accessing files on the disk. This is often an easy thing to do –if I’ve loaded a file from an external disk into an application, I just close the document or quit the application entirely. If I’ve goofed and am still using files on the drive, OS X will refuse to unmount the drive and will display the error dialog I’ve pasted above. 2

But often it’s less than obvious which application or function built-in to the operating system is using a file on the drive. There are applications that don’t play nice, and keep file handles open to files on a disk even after you’ve closed all documents that use those files 3. There are functions built into the operating system that access files on a disk without calling any attention to themselves. This error message could and should be a hell of a lot more informative and useful.

A simple set of commands in Terminal 4 can reveal which application is using a file on a particular disk. Since this information is available, is incredibly useful, and can be quickly retrieved in the Terminal, I see no reason that it is not just included in the initial error message. Telling me that a disk is still in use is not nearly as useful as telling me that a disk is still in use by Microsoft Word, or that a disk is still being shared with another computer.

In this case, the terminal command “lsof | egrep -i 400Gb” reported that a process named “smbd” was still using the drive. Since I’m a Unix geek this is useful information to me, but since OS X tries to also be useful to people who wouldn’t know a Samba daemon if it ate their grandmother, this process should be simplified. In an ideal world, the error message above would read “The disk ‘400Gb_Thing’ is in use by OS X’s Windows file sharing. Would you like to stop sharing this drive and eject it?” and would feature both “OK” and “Cancel Ejection” buttons.

This is a no-brainer. Apple, please fix. Thanks.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

  1. It’s a good idea to actually unmount disks prior to unplugging them, modern filesystems need to be given a proper send-off before disconnection to keep the data in good shape. ↩︎
  2. Windows users (and I am one), please refrain from feeling smug at this tale of Mac woe. Don’t get me started on the Windows “Safely Remove Hardware” dialogue and how much fun it is to try to remember the model numbers of each of my external drives so that I can find them in that list. It’s unconscionable that this feature wasn’t redesigned for Windows Vista. They must have used a single USB drive as the test case. ↩︎
  3. I often just have to quit Final Cut Pro before ejecting a drive for this reason, sometimes it just won’t let go of a file even when all FCP projects have been closed and I’m looking at an empty Browser ↩︎
  4. “lsof | egrep -i portion-of-disk-name”, or in this case “lsof | egrep -i 400Gb”, without the quotes. ↩︎

A note to Canon about their Rebel T1i DSLR and its marketing drivel

Wednesday, March 25th, 2009
The new Canon Digital Rebel T1i camera
Good people of Canon, please note: 1080p20 is NOT an HD video standard. Please strike all mention of “Full HD” that refer to your new camera’s 1080p recording capability from the press release for the Canon Digital Rebel T1i. Thanks.

Now for those of you who don’t work at Canon, the following is a bit of explanation for the above statement.

Canon has just announced the latest addition to Canon’s lower-cost “Rebel” line of Digital SLRs, and like the professional model they released late last year 1, it features the ability to shoot high definition video at both 1920×1080 (1080p) and 1280×720 (720p) HD resolutions. Once word spreads of this affordable ($899 MSRP with kit lens) camera that shoots 1080p with SLR lenses, I expect there will be a wave of initial excitement amongst filmmakers. We’d all love to shoot 1080p HD video with great SLR glass, and achieve sharp images with shallow depth of field.

But this camera has a couple of serious drawbacks for filmmaking that are glossed over in the marketing copy, supreme among them the fact that the camera can only shoot its fantastic 1080p video at a paltry 20 frames per second. I’d excuse this as a simple hardware limitation and be happy they included video recording at all, but the fact that the camera’s press release touts the T1i’s 1080p recording capability while dissing on DSLRs that only record 720p video (cough, Nikon D90, cough), well, that’s just evil marketing.

Except for use as some weird stuttery effect, 1080×1920 footage at 20fps will be utterly useless 2, unusable, stupid, and the feature is not worthy of inclusion in what otherwise looks to be a fine product. To shoot usable video at that resolution, the Canon EOS Rebel T1i would need to shoot 1080p at least at 24 or 30fps, like it’s pricier cousin 3.

The cynic in me wonders if 20fps really pushing the limits of the T1i camera’s sensor and the Digic IV processor, or whether a marketing decision hamstrung the camera’s 1080p recording mode so as to not cannibalize sales of its full-framed 1080p30-capable cousin? Perhaps this issue can be fixed before launch, or after launch with a firmware update? If not, then Canon should cease bragging about how the camera’s useless “Full HD exceeds the quality found in HD ready (720) resolution devices“. If the only resolution the camera can record at 24p or above is 720p, then it doesn’t get to claim automatic superiority to cameras that only record 720p.

Addendum: Stu Maschwitz posted about his disappointment with the camera on his ProLost blog at about the time I began writing this post. If only I’d been following him on twitter I could’ve saved myself some typing and simply posted a link to his more succinct and entertaining post. 4

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

  1. EOS 5D Mark II ↩︎
  2. Useless for filmmaking purposes. It’ll still absolutely cremate the image quality of its 20fps competition –namely cell phone cameras and webcams. ↩︎
  3. again, the Canon EOS 5D Mark II ↩︎
  4. Though I am happy I wrote this screed if only for its second footnote. ↩︎

SmoothCam test #1: AJ developing a musical idea on a piano

Tuesday, March 24th, 2009


A SmoothCam Test – AJ testing an idea on the piano from ZachFine on Vimeo. Available in larger size for playback and/or download here.


This is a test of Final Cut Pro’s “SmoothCam” motion stabilization filter. I’ve set two videos side-by-side. On the left, the original clip. On the right, the SmoothCam version with the following settings:

Auto Scale: 1
Actual Scale: 138%
Translation Smooth: 1.5
Rotation Smooth: 2
Scale Smooth: 0
Mix: 100

The original clip was shot with a Canon HV20 mounted on a Steadicam Merlin, so it was fairly smooth to begin with. I was pleased with how well the SmoothCam filter ironed out the rotational skewing of the camera without being noticeable about it. I do wish the filter didn’t autoscale the entire clip to match the worst of the movement, and instead the adjusted clip could start with the wide and then smoothly scale in to cover the adjustments, then smoothly scale out for segments that were more stable. Had I shot with a higher shutter speed, the motion blur on the subject wouldn’t be as bad.

I’m sure I’ll end up using this SmoothCam filter on some footage one of these days. It’s a nice effect. I’ve already had FCP batch analyze all my footage from the SXSW festival. The fact that the filter works very quickly on clips whose motion has already been batch analyzed is a deal-maker.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Saint Motel “Stories” Live

Tuesday, March 24th, 2009

My cousin AJ edited together a live performance of the Saint Motel song Stories from their 2/15/2009 Spaceland “Zombie Prom” performance, using my previously posted footage along with footage from other video cameras that shot the same show. It’s paired with a non-burnt audio track that’s a huge improvement from the audio I captured.

https://vimeo.com/3497942
“Stories” – Live @ Spaceland (Zombie Prom 2.15.09) from SAINT MOTEL on Vimeo.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Final Cut Pro can batch analyze clips for stabilization, in the background yet

Monday, March 23rd, 2009
A screenshot of the Final Cut Pro Browser and Background Processes windows showing the SmoothCam Analysis in progress.
A screenshot of the Final Cut Pro Browser and Background Processes windows showing the SmoothCam Analysis in progress. Click the image to see it at a legibly large size.

I ran around the South by Southwest festival last week shooting behind-the-scenes video of my cousin AJ and his band on my Canon HV20, stabilized with a Steadicam Merlin. I’m still learning to use the Merlin –it is a fantastically engineered piece of kit, but it takes a light touch to float it about, and it’s much easier to use for choreographed moves than for impromptu run-and-gun documentary-style shooting.

Final Cut Pro and Motion both inherited a feature from Shake called “SmoothCam”, which is a motion stabilization filter. SmoothCam analyzes movement within a clip and moves the frame around to compensate for high-frequency movement while preserving the lower-frequency moves –i.e. it tries to remove bumps and vibrations while preserving smooth, intentional camera movements. I ran a few tests on some of my relatively smooth clips, and SmoothCam seemed very good at doing exactly that.

When the SmoothCam filter is applied to a clip, that clip is put into a queue and Final Cut Pro begins to analyze the motion in the clip. Once FCP’s analysis concludes 1 , the SmoothCam filter will have data to use for its calculations and its effect will finally become visible. One can then adjust the SmoothCam settings and see the results instantaneously (with a computer of sufficient power).

I’m happy to note that it is possible to have Final Cut Pro analyze the motion of a batch of clips, and then later if the SmoothCam filter is applied to any of these clips its results can be seen without delay. The motion analysis data for each clip is written to disk alongside the clips themselves.

Since I may or may not want to use the SmoothCam filter on many of my clips, and I don’t plan to do any more editing on my computer tonight, I’ve set FCP to batch analyze the motion in all of my footage from the last week. To do so, I enabled the “SmoothCam” column in FCP’s Browser, selected all the clips I wanted analyzed, right-clicked in the column and chose “Run Analysis” from the clip’s contextual pop-up menu. Now the analysis is puttering away, and tomorrow I can play.

The things one can learn by glancing at the manual!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

  1. The entire clip is analyzed, regardless whether only a portion of it is in use in a timeline. A clip’s In and Out points are ignored. The analysis can take a while, and I would strongly recommend converting any clips in a long-gop format such as HDV to Prores beforehand for markedly faster analysis. ↩︎

“Heroes” continues its downward spiral and I keep watching

Friday, March 6th, 2009
I just came across this review of the TV show Heroes, written last December. It’s a terrific summary of the problems with the show. If anything, the show has gotten worse since that review was written.

I’ve been rewatching the first season, and I recommend it to anyone, with a caveat: Season one began very poorly. Somewhere around the fifth episode the series magically became tremendously improved; The storylines compelling, the dialogue well-written. This improvement continued through much of the first season. I wonder what caused this to happen? Maybe the writers got into their groove? maybe there was a change of personnel?

I continue to watch the show’s current, disappointing, season, for a couple of reasons. One being the reason cited by that author 1 –but also because at its worst the show is often well-scored, well acted, and well shot. I just wish the writing would take the same miraculously and unpredictably positive turn it did during its first season. I’m waiting for that turn to occur, so that I can recommend the current series to friends with the same bizarre caveat that I append to my recommendation of the first season: “Cringe your way through the first 4 episodes. It’ll be worth it.”

  1. “Because no one can turn away from a good train wreck” ↩︎

Michel Gondry’s Green Hornet to get crafty?

Tuesday, February 24th, 2009
Perhaps Christopher Nolan opened the floodgates by starting with creepy 1 arthouse thrillers (Following, Memento) and moving on to direct a couple of wildly successful films about a ordinary billionaire playboy who becomes a chiropterid-themed superhero during his bouts of dysphonia, but I’m shocked and delighted to read that director Michel Gondry (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Some of the best music videos ever) is negotiating to direct 2 The Green Hornet. If you know who Michel Gondry is, or if like me you seek out every piece of his cinematic output, you know how wacky and possibly brilliant a choice he is for this project.

I was a little shocked and delighted previously when Hong Kong auteur Stephen Chow (Kung Fu Hustle, Shaolin Soccer) had been picked to direct, but as left-field a choice as Chow seemed, he at least is known for very slick and populist action films. Gondry’s work always has a playfulness, is steeped in a childlike sense of wonder, and generally has a more crafty than slick aesthetic.

I now expect Green Lantern to face his arch enemy “Ball of Yarn Man”. They’ll fight each other with cardboard weapons decorated in crayon while running down the up escalator. Anything hit by these weapons would grow or shrink 10x in size. 3 All real skies will be replaced by ones made of blue construction paper with puffy cotton-ball clouds. All the camera-work will have a perfectly-simulated hand-held look.

And I’ll love it.

Here are a couple of Michel Gondry clips from youtube, to whet the appetite:

  1. Creepy and awesome, I might add. Do yourself a favor and rent Following. ↩︎
  2. Why does everyone always write “…is in negotiations…”? Negotiating is not a passive activity. ↩︎
  3. The age-old blow-to-the-crotch gag could serve up more comic relief than usual given these circumstances, not that Gondry goes for cheap-shots. ↩︎

Oscar Update

Sunday, February 22nd, 2009
Repent Oscars
I drove past this man tonight, he is standing about as close to the Kodak Theater (site of the Academy Awards) as traffic is allowed to go. I did not take his message to heart –this year I’m both biased and have a stake in the outcome. Tonight I’m rooting for everyone involved with The Curious Case of Benjamin Button to become idolaters.

Get Your War On Animation (possibly not safe for work)

Friday, November 28th, 2008
Get Your War On  Cindy Mccain - 236.Com - Video
"Accounts Payable" leans against a wall as he tells it like it is to "Accounts Receivable" in this still frame from the animation.
The sociopolitical comic series “Get Your War On” has now spawned a series of video shorts that maintain the look of the originals shockingly well 1.

I just watched the “Thanksgiving Day” video. The jokes come fast and hard, it took me two viewings to catch them all.

The full set of 19 videos can be found here.

This is a worthy port 2 of the comic to video. Definitely worth a look if you don’t mind gobs of profanity and political humor that leans sharply to the left.

  1. Created using animation tools built originally for the film “Waking Life”, I believe. ↩︎
  2. Port – modify (software) for use on a different machine or platform ↩︎

Teri Garr kicks ass

Wednesday, July 30th, 2008
Youngfrank Tgarr2A still of Her Royal Highness Teri Garr 1 from the fantastic film Young Frankenstein

There’s a question that often pops up when people are trying to suss out another person’s interests, ideals, knowledge of history, etc. Something along the lines of “Who are the five world figures, living or dead, with whom you’d most like to sit down and have a conversation over a tray of spam musubi?” I swear every answer to that question I’ve heard from a well-meaning white person includes Nelson Mandela and/or Ghandi. I mean no disrespect to either of those esteemed gentlemen, but with one refreshingly candid interview Teri Garr has knocked them both off of my list. 2

An excerpt related to Young Frankenstein:

…it was like when the teacher says to stop laughing, and all you can do is laugh more. Mel would say, “Can we do another take with no laughing?” And we’d say, “We’ll try.” We would laugh at everything. Marty Feldman–God, was he funny. When I went to see the show in New York, I went backstage, and I said, “You’re all doomed.” Because everyone is dead from that movie! Well, not everyone. But Madeline, and Peter Boyle, and Marty. And myself, I have one foot in the grave and one on a banana peel.

She’s recently written an autobiography, entitled Speedbumps: Flooring It Through Hollywood 3. I plan to check it out.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

  1. She has multiple sclerosis, and has said she now hates the letters M and S, “and I certainly took the Ms. off the front of my name. I now go as your Royal Highness Teri Garr.” ↩︎
  2. Honestly, what question have those two figures not already been asked while they shared spam musubi with Abraham Lincoln, the Dalai Lama, Jesus, and Floyd from accounting? ↩︎
  3. Apparently she wanted to title the book “Does This Wheelchair Make Me Look Fat?” but was dissuaded by the publisher. ↩︎