A note to Canon about their Rebel T1i DSLR and its marketing drivel

The new Canon Digital Rebel T1i camera
Good people of Canon, please note: 1080p20 is NOT an HD video standard. Please strike all mention of “Full HD” that refer to your new camera’s 1080p recording capability from the press release for the Canon Digital Rebel T1i. Thanks.

Now for those of you who don’t work at Canon, the following is a bit of explanation for the above statement.

Canon has just announced the latest addition to Canon’s lower-cost “Rebel” line of Digital SLRs, and like the professional model they released late last year 1, it features the ability to shoot high definition video at both 1920×1080 (1080p) and 1280×720 (720p) HD resolutions. Once word spreads of this affordable ($899 MSRP with kit lens) camera that shoots 1080p with SLR lenses, I expect there will be a wave of initial excitement amongst filmmakers. We’d all love to shoot 1080p HD video with great SLR glass, and achieve sharp images with shallow depth of field.

But this camera has a couple of serious drawbacks for filmmaking that are glossed over in the marketing copy, supreme among them the fact that the camera can only shoot its fantastic 1080p video at a paltry 20 frames per second. I’d excuse this as a simple hardware limitation and be happy they included video recording at all, but the fact that the camera’s press release touts the T1i’s 1080p recording capability while dissing on DSLRs that only record 720p video (cough, Nikon D90, cough), well, that’s just evil marketing.

Except for use as some weird stuttery effect, 1080×1920 footage at 20fps will be utterly useless 2, unusable, stupid, and the feature is not worthy of inclusion in what otherwise looks to be a fine product. To shoot usable video at that resolution, the Canon EOS Rebel T1i would need to shoot 1080p at least at 24 or 30fps, like it’s pricier cousin 3.

The cynic in me wonders if 20fps really pushing the limits of the T1i camera’s sensor and the Digic IV processor, or whether a marketing decision hamstrung the camera’s 1080p recording mode so as to not cannibalize sales of its full-framed 1080p30-capable cousin? Perhaps this issue can be fixed before launch, or after launch with a firmware update? If not, then Canon should cease bragging about how the camera’s useless “Full HD exceeds the quality found in HD ready (720) resolution devices“. If the only resolution the camera can record at 24p or above is 720p, then it doesn’t get to claim automatic superiority to cameras that only record 720p.

Addendum: Stu Maschwitz posted about his disappointment with the camera on his ProLost blog at about the time I began writing this post. If only I’d been following him on twitter I could’ve saved myself some typing and simply posted a link to his more succinct and entertaining post. 4

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

  1. EOS 5D Mark II ↩︎
  2. Useless for filmmaking purposes. It’ll still absolutely cremate the image quality of its 20fps competition –namely cell phone cameras and webcams. ↩︎
  3. again, the Canon EOS 5D Mark II ↩︎
  4. Though I am happy I wrote this screed if only for its second footnote. ↩︎

2 Responses to 'A note to Canon about their Rebel T1i DSLR and its marketing drivel'

  1. Sachin Says:

    I agree that 1080p20 is stupid. but

    This is a consumer camera. it’s the low end DSLR. People who have it will probably be shooting and uploading to youtube “hd” or something. Of course it would be nice if this “cheap” camera also could appease videographers, but that’s not the goal

    I wouldn’t be surprised if the camera technically cannot do 1080p30

    Also, digital cameras are all about marketing. Megapixels? come on, it’s a race to higher numbers. obviously these guys will say/do anything to make their cameras sell, even if it’s not the best thing for the industry

  2. zach Says:

    Adding and touting high quality 1080p video capture in such a low-cost camera is like offering a starving child a slice of bread. Us hungry filmmakers get crotchety when it is revealed that the bread is made of rubber. Man, this is one tortured analogy –what I mean to say is that it is disappointment at the camera’s wasted potential that has made me so sour. Sure, it’s a consumer camera, and I’m sure it will shoot perfectly acceptable youtube videos that’ll look better than the average webcam clip (assuming youtube can deal with 1080p20), but the camera doesn’t live up to its hype or its potential.

    I’d believe that the camera’s hardware can’t do 1080p30, but asking a camera that can shoot 1080p20 to just shoot 3.976 more frames of video per second doesn’t seem to me to be asking for too much. I’d even be happy if they skipped and interpolated past a few pixels to hit a usable frame rate like 24fps let alone 30fps. Commercial video cameras will drop resolution due to hardware constraints or to save bandwidth, but rarely do they touch the frame rate as such a compromise goes too far. Many of the commercial 1080p video formats drop 23% of that format’s horizontal resolution (i.e., they record 1440×1080 with non-square pixels) and still manage to produce a more detailed image than 720p. There are tradeoffs and compromises that lead to usable products, and then there are simply poor decisions. If the Canon T1i was meant to shoot usable 1080p, 20fps was a very poor decision.

    The frame rate choice leads me to further believe that Canon’s SLR division doesn’t really understand video formats. First the EOS 5D Mark II, the expensive DSLR that does shoot 1080p30, doesn’t shoot 1080p24 or any of the 720p formats. The camera’s hardware and processor can obviously deal with these less bandwidth and processor intensive streams, so including those features would seem a no-brainer. But at least that camera shoots one real HD standard, 1080p30.

    I’d agree with you that digital cameras are all about marketing, but I won’t let it slide. I like Canon. They tend to put out a great and well-engineered products (two SLRs and $several thousand in EF lenses sitting in my camera bag attest to my appreciation of their products). I consider the video feature on this camera to be a mistake, and the marketing of it to be a blot on the history of an otherwise tip-top Camera company.

    C’mon Canon, just release a firmware a couple months after launch that allows the T1i to magically have the ability to shoot 1080p24. It has to be possible, you’re Canon! Kick Nikon in their consumer DSLR’s puny 720p24 bollocks! Your taunt-filled press release sure makes it sound like you want to. Get out there and kick some ass.

Leave a Reply