Geeky

EPA should not list combined ratings for upcoming electric vehicles

Monday, February 15th, 2010

I’ve been reading up on the Chevy Volt, Nissan Leaf, and other electric cars. It seems the EPA is trying to figure out how to rate such cars for their efficiency. Unfortunately, perhaps due to the desire of automakers wishing to impress consumers with big numbers that relate to current labels, they’re leaning towards relating the efficiency of electric vehicles in miles per gallon or combined ratings that try to reduce the efficiencies or range of multiple methods of energy storage into single numbers that are difficult to entangle into real information.

This next paragraph is going to sound like a grade-school mathematics word problem, but bear with me. The Chevy Volt has an electric motor and a battery. When the battery is depleted, a gas generator kicks in to power the electric motor and extend the range. Chevy says their battery will power 40-miles of driving. So a person who drives less than 40-miles a day might only use gas on rare occasions. So for that person, a displayed rating of 40-miles-per-charge would be the most useful rating. For a person who regularly takes a 400 mile drive from Los Angeles to San Francisco, 90% of their drive would be powered by the generator. For them, the number they’d need to see would be how may miles-per-gallon they’d get. The EPA’s current label design would fail to communicate anything of use to either the people in these examples.

Instead, they’re doing some kind of weird combined rating that relates to kilowatt-hours used per 100 miles of travel. This awards the Chevy Volt a rating of 236 mpg. Sounds impressive, but that’s not a number that relates to one’s experience of using the car. I typically drive less than 100 miles a week. If I were in the market for an electric vehicle, I’d use zero gallons of gas most weeks. ∞ mpg?

 Files Mini-E-Sticker

Here’s the EPA draft label, for the BMW Mini-E. That car can travel 156 miles on a single charge. It’d be much more useful if that range were just printed on the label, rather than “33kW-hr/100 miles (equivalent to 102 MPG)”.

EPA, if you’re listening, please label electric cars as follows. Show the distance the car can go on a single battery charge. If the vehicle switches to another fuel when the battery is depleted, then separately show the distance it can go on that fuel along with the size of that fuel tank. Nice and simple. 2 big numbers (distance ranges), one small number (size of secondary fuel tank). The car manufacturers wouldn’t be able to tout awesomely high miles-per-gallon ratings, but it’d be a more honest and intelligible way to rate methods of propulsion that use fuel not measured by the gallon.

iTunes sharing over the internet using Back to my Mac and ssh port forwarding

Monday, February 8th, 2010

I was at work the other week, doing a repetitive task of the sort that provides an opportunity to listen to music. I’d recently purchased an album and had stored it in the iTunes library on my home computer, but had not yet loaded the new songs onto my iPhone. There had to be a way to make iTunes at home share its music to my work computer so that I could listen to the new music. A few internet searches turned up some interesting information as well as a solution.

The crippled feature to be healed and exploited

Apple’s iTunes software has the ability to share selected playlists or entire libraries of music to other computers on a local network running iTunes. This means that if you have a large collection of music on your desktop computer, you can browse and listen to music from its library from a different room, streamed to your laptop. Or if you work in an office, and your coworkers have iTunes running on their machines and set to share, their shared libraries will automatically appear in the left column of iTunes running on your machine and you can play from them. It all works very seamlessly, on a local network. Possibly due to agreements made between apple and the recording industry, the sharing feature only works between computers on a local network, not between computers on the internet at large.

How iTunes sharing works

When a user tells iTunes to enable sharing in that application’s preferences, iTunes advertises that service on port 3689 of the local network using “Bonjour“, the name for Apple’s implementation of the Zeroconf standard. Bonjour is used by iTunes, iPhoto, and other applications to advertise and to find servers on a local network, such as within a home or office.

If a copy of iTunes is running on any other computers that are on the local network, those instances of iTunes will notice the advertisement of an iTunes share on the network, and will display the name of that iTunes share in the left column of the window. The user can then click that shared Library and play songs from it on their computer. The playlists and songs stream over the network from the sharer to the sharee. Unfortunately in my case, iTunes running on my laptop at work couldn’t see the iTunes share served from my computer at home, because my home computer is miles away and not connected to the same local network as my laptop.

Bringing the remote network closer

The following link pointed the way to a solution: 1

REMOTE ITUNES SHARING

I recognized a familiar Unix trick in their tip: Port forwarding over a secure shell connection. Of course! If one could make a secure shell connection (abbreviated in the command “ssh”) to a remote computer, one could then do what’s called “port forwarding”, and forward all communications on a port on the remote machine to a port on the local machine. This would transport both the advertisement of the iTunes share and the actual sharing itself from the remote network to the local network. I’d never actually executed port forwarding over ssh before, but I’d heard of it, and between their example and the man page for the ‘ssh’ command, it all became clear. The tip first requires that one knows the IP address of the remote computer, and then shows the command to connect to the remote machine, grab any communications on port 3689 (the port used by iTunes sharing), transport it encrypted to the local machine, and repeat it on port 36890 of the local machine. The command looks like this (hover your mouse over any portion of the command to see an explanation of that portion):

$ ssh -fNL *:36890:127.0.0.1:3689 USER@REMOTE-HOST

After that command successfully concludes, the iTunes share on the remote computer will be accessible to computers on the local network, except they won’t be able to see that it’s there. The second command in their document uses OS X’s built-in “dns-sd” command to advertise that there is an iTunes share on port 36890 of the local computer. It is this advertisement that will make the iTunes share appear in the sidebars of any copy of iTunes running on the network:

$ dns-sd -R "Remote iTunes" _daap._tcp local 36890 &

I was confident that this would all work, but for one snag. Like most people, my home computer only has an address on its local network, it doesn’t have its own internet address. The computer is connected to a router. The router has an IP address on the internet and an IP address on the local network and uses what’s called “Network Address Translation” to distribute connections from the outside internet to all the computers on the local network. If I tried to connect to the IP address of my home connection, I’d be connecting to the router, not my home computer with its trove of music. Luckily a solution was within reach.

Locating the remote computer using Back to My Mac

I recently purchased a “MobileMe” subscription, which includes a service called “Back to my Mac“. I’ll let Apple’s marketing folk, who’ve obviously seen Buckaroo Banzai, explain “Back to My Mac” for me:

Wherever you go, there’s your Mac.

Back to My Mac puts any Mac OS X Leopard- or Snow Leopard-based Mac you use within easy reach. MobileMe finds your remote Mac computers over the Internet and displays them in the Finder on the Mac you’re using. So you can connect from anywhere with just a click. Edit and save documents, open applications, and move folders. With Back to My Mac Screen Sharing, you can control your remote Mac as though you’re sitting in front of it.

I have been using the Back to My Mac service to copy files to and from my remote computer from work, and to occasionally take control of my home computer’s screen from work. The service must be punching through the router using port-forwarding and registering a temporary domain name for my home computer which can be accessed from the outside internet. I figured that if I could find out this domain name, it would be worth a try to use it to connect from work to the home computer and set up ssh port forwarding of the iTunes share. A search turned up this article:

10.5: How to use ssh using ‘Back to My Mac’

The writer of that article explains exactly how to determine the Back to My Mac domain name at which one can find their remote computer. When I tried the first method described, it did not work. As it turns out, that method works for short computer names, but my home computer’s name is long, and Back to My Mac truncates it and adds a few random (?) numbers when assigning the domain name. The second method they mention does work. I can easily determine the name assigned to my remote machine by choosing “Shell > New Remote Connection…” in the Terminal application’s menubar. In the “New Remote Connection” window that appears, I choose ‘ssh’ in the service column and my remote computer’s name in the ‘Server’ column. There, in the field at the bottom of the New Remote Connection window will appear the command for making a ssh connection to my home computer. It’s not the same ssh connection command that will be used to do port forwarding, but the last portion of it does show me the exact domain name that will resolve to my home computer.

Victory

Whenever I feel the mood, I can now run the following two commands and then sit at work listening to streaming music stored on my home computer:

$ ssh -fNL :36890:127.0.0.1:3689 myComputerName.myMobileMeID.members.mac.com.

$ dns-sd -R "Zach's Remote iTunes FTW" _daap._tcp local 36890 &



Thanks Y’all

Thank yous are due to the writers of:
  1. All the solutions written below involve the use of the Terminal application and the command-line. If you’ve never played with such, give it a shot. Stop kvetching and open /Applications/Utilities/Terminal. You paid for a Unix operating system when you bought your Mac, you might as well try exploring some of its inner awesomeness. ↩︎

FCP howto: Use Batch Export to create a directory of still frames from a bin of clips

Wednesday, February 3rd, 2010

If you’ve got a bunch of clips in a Final Cut Pro Browser window, and you’d like to quickly generate a still frame for each clip, you can use the “Still Image” feature of FCP’s ancient “Batch Export” feature to automate much of the process. Here’s how:

Rt Overlays (Ignored By Utest)
1. Choose a representative frame in each clip. (Click any of these images to see them nice and big.

Making Stills From Fcp Step 2
2. Send the clips to FCP’s Batch Export feature and bring up its “Settings” window.

Exporting Stills From Fcp Step 3
3. Choose the destination for the exported files and set Batch Export to create still images.

The result will be a folder full-resolution PNG images, each named after its parent clip, deposited in the chosen destination folder.

I often end up processing directories full of such uncompressed images further using the excellent command-line Imagemagick utilities using the tcsh shell’s 1 “foreach” command to iterate through all the images. 2 It generally goes a little something like this:

$ tcsh 3
% cd directory_of_images 4
% foreach foo (*.png) 5
foreach? convert -geometry 330x800 "$foo" "$foo:r.jpg" 6
foreach? rm "$foo" 7
foreach? end 8

The result of this command is a set of JPEG-compressed images, one per clip selected in step 2, each resized proportionally to fit within a 330×800 rectangle.

  1. This is also easy to do with OS X’s default bash shell, but I’m more fluent in tcsh. ↩︎
  2. You may prefer GraphicConverter, Photoshop, or MS Paint. Imagemagick combined with the command line is mad fast for both image transformations and automatically renaming files. ↩︎
  3. Switching to the tcsh for this because I have yet to internalize Bash’s foreach syntax. ↩︎
  4. If you’re unfamiliar with command lines and shells, please note that the “%” character here represents the tcsh command-prompt, the “$” in the previous line represents the typical Bash command-prompt. Don’t type these characters in your commands, they’re just here for show. ↩︎
  5. “foo” is a placeholder of my choosing. There’s nothing special about the string “foo”. You can replace it with anything you like, such as “image”, “placeholder”, or “your_mom”. Just make sure to use the same string in place of all the “$foo” commands below. ↩︎
  6. Each time tcsh iterates through your commands, it will replace the string “$foo” with the filename of an image from the set chosen by “*.png”, which is every file in the directory ending in “.png”. Adding a “:r” to “$foo” indicates that tcsh should expand the filename but leave off the period and filename extension –in this case “$foo:r.jpg” removes “.png” from the file and adds “.jpg” in its place. The quotes around “$foo” are optional if your filenames do not contain spaces or special characters. ↩︎
  7. Removing the original png file because all I ever wanted were the tiny JPEGs. ↩︎
  8. One more note from Captain Obvious: If you try to copy and paste any of these commands, be sure not to copy and paste the superscript numbers that lead to these footnotes. ↩︎

assistant editor Unix tricks

Monday, January 25th, 2010

It’s time to take apart some Final Cut Pro xml and add some newly received VFX clips to the VFX database. One of these days, I’ll explain all of these steps and how they might be useful in other workflows. For now, enjoy a look at a relaxing vacation from graphical user interfaces and mouse-clicks; A trip to the Terminal. If you have any Unix or XML knowledge, there might be something of interest in here.

Assistant-2:20100125 CAB$ xmlstarlet sel -t -m "//children/clip"\
-v "name" -o "," \
-v "out - in" -o "," -v "in" -o "," -v "out" -o ","\
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/start" -o "," \
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/end" -o ","\
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/file/timecode/frame" -o ","\
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/file/name" -o ","\
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/file/timecode/string" -o ","\
-v "media/video/track/clipitem/file/timecode/reel/name"\
-n 20100123_vfx_received.xml | tee 20100123_vfx_received.csv

52A-2_01_VFX_v1,178,0,178,0,178,,52A-2_01_VFX_v1.mov,,
52A-2_02_VFX_v1,141,0,141,0,141,,52A-2_02_VFX_v1.mov,,
52B-2_01_VFX_v1,152,0,152,0,152,,52B-2_01_VFX_v1.mov,,
53-3A_01_VFX_v4,307,0,307,0,307,,53-3A_01_VFX_v4.mov,,
54-3A_01_VFX_v1,188,0,188,0,188,,54-3A_01_VFX_v1.mov,,
C100_C016_0920LS_03_VFX_v1,102,0,102,0,102,,C100_C016_0920LS_03_VFX_v1.mov,,
C102_C011_0903RU_03_VFX_v1,79,0,79,0,79,,C102_C011_0903RU_03_VFX_v1.mov,,
C102_C011_0903RU_04_VFX_v4,256,0,256,0,256,,C102_C011_0903RU_04_VFX_v4.mov,,
C102_C011_0903RU_05_VFX_v2,200,0,200,0,200,,C102_C011_0903RU_05_VFX_v2.mov,,
C102_C011_0903RU_06_VFX_v2,147,0,147,0,147,,C102_C011_0903RU_06_VFX_v2.mov,,

Assistant-2:20100125 CAB$ cd thumbs/
Assistant-2:thumbs CAB$ tcsh
[Assistant-2:additions/20100125/thumbs] CAB% foreach foo (*.png)
foreach? convert -geometry 330x800 "$foo" "$foo:r.jpg"
foreach? rm "$foo"
foreach? end
[Assistant-2:additions/20100125/thumbs] CAB%

The starting point is a bin of clips in an FCP project. I’ve exported that bin as FCP XML, and have also batch exported the clips inside it as stills (to PNG, the default). The commands above are the meat of the process. Then the comma-separated-value list of clips I generate with the xmlstarlet command gets imported into an openoffice (or Excel) spreadsheet (a step I’ve ommitted here), and is massaged into a csv format for import into a Filemaker Pro database of VFX clips. Finally I import the thumbnails for each clip into the database. Fun stuff, pretty much.

Leaving Michigan

Friday, October 23rd, 2009
Montcalm road
Montcalm road, Lowell, Michigan
My server’s been offline the better part of the last month due to the fact that I’ve been out of town and some errant process filled up my swap partition 1. So I’ll be backtracking in subsequent posts and filling in some details of my Michigan sojourn that I haven’t yet had the ability to post.

 Mg 1289
When the traffic signs are riddled with gunshot, it’s probably best to wear orange clothing and remove your bambi costume.
But here’s a bit of news from the present, surrounded by photos from my last drive into the countryside 2: I’ve been in Michigan for a couple of months working on a film, and today I’ll be heading back to LA to continue working on the film for another month. My plan then entails relaxing for a couple of days with nothing to do, then a freak out and mad scramble to find another gig. I’ll be back in Los Angeles come Monday 10/26/2009. Let the wild rumpus begin 3.

 Mg 1386
Does the windmill at the center of this field really serve any function at all? And what crop is that? It’s not corn, not wheat. Everything in this photo might represent form without function. I’d have trudged further out into this field to get you a better view, but the wacko crop made it difficult and I was worried the farmer would appear and shoot me.
I will miss some things about this town. I’ll save them for a later post, which would have been an earlier post but for the problem noted in paragraph 1 of this post. Ah well, life goes on. It’s nice to be back online, and will be nice to be back home.
 Mg 1243
Oh hey, a cat. Who doesn’t love cats?

  1. Yeah, one would think that swapping partitions was a “Free Love” era tradition, but it continues in all modern operating systems. There are even key exchanges. ↩︎
  2. Photos shot on 10/18/2009, click any of them to see them writ large. ↩︎
  3. “Begin” is an anagram for “being”. Think about it. Stop thinking about it. ↩︎

Interesting product: IOGEAR Mobile Digital Scribe $44.99 after rebate at Amazon

Thursday, September 24th, 2009
Iogear - Gpen200N - Mobile Digital Scribe
I like writing, sketching, and I like to play with the odd electronic gadget, so I thought this IOGear “Mobile Digital Scribe” (AKA the GPEN200N) seemed an intriguing device. This weirdly technologized pen can be had for $44.95 at Amazon.com, at least until the end of September. 1

I bought and received mine, taking funds from my geeky-and-probably-unnecessary-device budget. A close look reveals that there are two parts to this gadget; The pen and the base station. The base station clips to a piece or pad of paper, and is used to record the movement of the pen, it features a single button that can be held-down to turn the base station on and off 2, and can be pressed quickly in order to indicate that the user is sketching a new page (up to 50 pages worth of scribblings can be recorded at a stretch). The base connects to the computer via USB cable, and the included software will instantly transfer any recorded notes to a specified location on the computer as TIFF images. The USB connection also charges the base station’s internal battery. The pen uses a couple of those tiny watch or hearing aid batteries, and shuts itself off whenever its not moving, so apparently they don’t need to be replaced often. 3

I connected the base to my computer, updated its firmware to 1.76 so that it’d work with Mac OS X, rebooted my computer, unplugged the base, clipped it to some paper, wrote a bit, then plugged the base back into the computer. Everything I wrote transferred over to the computer automatically as a tiff file (deposited into a folder I’d pre-designated), and looked very very good. I’d guess that the base unit stores pen movements in a vector-based format, which is then rendered to a tiff file after it’s transferred to the computer.

OCR test
I tried the bundled OCR 4 software, “MyScript Notes Light” on Windows XP inside VMware Fusion. On my first test, it worked surprisingly well. Subsequent tests were not so successful. I think it gets confused when it tries to emulate the layout of text written in lines that are not completely horizontal. I also scribbled a couple of Chinese characters (ni hao) and it recognized those and converted them to text (in a separate pass with the OCR software set to simplified Chinese). There’s no reason that the high-resolution TIFF images created by the pen couldn’t be opened in more capable OCR software, perhaps resulting in more usable transcriptions.

Mouse mode does work, the pen can be used to draw and drag on the computer. A click can be executed by pressing the point of the pen down or by clicking the pen’s side button. There’s a bit of lag, which would suck for gaming, but mouse mode could potentially be of use with photoshop (note: the pen is not pressure sensitive).

I half-busted one of the base unit’s clips trying to clip it to a stack of paper larger than it can accept. So my recommendation would be “don’t do what I did”. Other than that hiccup, my thoughts on the IOGear Mobile Digital Scribe (or GPEN200N) are positive so far.

  1. It’s currently marked down from $129 (WTFLOL) to $64.95, and then there’s a $20 mail-in rebate. ↩︎
  2. It took me a day to figure this out –the little guide it ships with says nothing about this, and holding the button produces some bizarre twiddlings of items on the base station’s LCD display, animations that don’t appear to portend an imminent shutdown, before it indeed shuts down. ↩︎
  3. Whether or not those batteries will ever need to replaced will depend on whether or not I tire quickly of this new toy or actually find it useful and take notes with it daily. ↩︎
  4. Optical Character Recognition – it converts one’s writing into text. ↩︎

The wine that will “change lives, cities, and ways of thinking.”

Sunday, September 13th, 2009
Img 3043-1
Strangely-enough, this wine is marked down to the price range at which I’d be willing to buy one of its wheeled namesakes.

I saw this wine bottle on the clearance rack at Meijers and, though this alcoholic beverage likely has nothing to do with any two-wheeled self-balancing electric scooter, I couldn’t help but remember all the Segway hype from 2001.

The quote in this post’s Title is from Segway creator Dean Kamen, who has invented many extremely-cool devices, but his predictions for a future built around that scooter have yet to be realized. This Slate article does a good job recapping the more outlandish bits of Segway hype and expectations.

Stirling Engine diagram from Wikipedia Commons

I remember rumors circulating before the Segway launch that Kamen was going to release some kind of antigravity flying machine based on the Stirling engine. I have no idea what that means, but the diagram of a Stirling engine over at Wikipedia is the most unintentionally suggestive engineering-related image I’ve ever seen. I’ve put a tiny thumbnail of it at right, but for greater impact view it at full resolution over at Wikipedia.

Img 3044-1
Hints of chocolate, blackcurrant, and outsized expectations.

On one’s twitter popularity

Monday, August 31st, 2009

Twitter Followers Stats For @Zachnfine By Twittercounter-2
Illustration courtesy of the site "twittercounter".

The title of this post is a little misleading. It should probably read,”On my twitter popularity; In which I compare my number of followers to that of the stars in heaven and, on finding the comparison unfavorable, decide twitter popularity an unwholesome pursuit. This I’d follow with a few choice Icarus references and the exclamation that I prefer to keep my feet firmly planted on terra firma.”

I’d have gone with that as this post’s title, but it would not fit into twitter’s 140-character limit.

A curious bit of advertising from Microsoft Bing

Saturday, August 22nd, 2009

When one searches for anything on Microsoft Bing that has the potential to be related to anything that can be bought, sold, or processed, the search engine presents several links to commercial related items at the top of the search results, often emblazoned with the ‘Bing cashback’ icon to indicate that the item can be purchased at a discount by finding it through Bing. I thought the following commercialized Bing link was rather interesting:

Female to Male cashback from BING

Toslink Search
Click this thumbnail to see the example writ large.

Any guesses as to the subject of my initial search? Here’s a hint: the search was completely unrelated to gender reassignment surgical procedures, but it does warm my heart that on such operations a person might receive a Bing cashback percentage return. Thanks Microsoft!

At right is an image with a little more context, in which you can see my query and the placement of Bing’s interesting little ad. Click it to see it full size.

Bing vs. Google –- browser load times compared

Tuesday, August 4th, 2009
I remember back in the early days of the internet, before Google’s search engine produced results that were so clearly better than everyone else’s 1, I immediately favored it because their uncluttered webpage and the search results loaded at lightning-speed when compared to the competition.

These days Google is king of search and their remaining competitors are also-rans. Microsoft, in a major play for the search market has revamped their search engine. Not content to merely improve the engine, Microsoft has also decided to change its name. 2 So The engine previously known as “MSN Search”, then “Windows Live Search”, then “Live Search”, has been rechristened to “Bing”. I maintain that they were undoubtedly inspired to use the name “Bing” as an homage to this great moment in the film “Groundhog Day”. 3

My cursory test of Bing shows that it’s a decent search engine, but I don’t have to scan as far through Google’s results to find links I consider relevant. For example, in a search for “Bing” on both engines, Google returns Microsoft’s search engine’s page as its first non-sponsored result 4 and the wikipedia article on the service as the 3rd result. Microsoft Bing’s results first show several “News about Bing” links at the top, followed by a link to the Bing page, and then the “Bing Crosby” article at Wikipedia. The wikipedia page on Bing is two links later, halfway down the page. Since I was not looking for news articles on Bing, Google’s search results were better for me, with everything I wanted within the first 3 results. This isn’t a dealbreaker. I could still find what I needed in Bing’s results, and I’d be shocked if Microsoft doesn’t continue to improve their service –starting with algorithms that move more frequently-clicked results for a given query to the top of the list 5.

Google edges ahead in this cursory test, but not enough to cause me to scowl and turn away from Bing in disgust. How about speed? I cleared my browser cache, opened up Safari’s Network Timeline, and loaded google.com and bing.com one after the other. The results are telling:

Graph of time to load bing

graph of time to load google

A proper fail. Bing’s page is obviously bloated compared to Google’s, and took about 5x longer to appear in my browser and 10x longer to completely load than Google (4.26 seconds vs. 478ms). This isn’t just due to Bing including 82kb of pretty pictures in the front page, there’s also a significant difference in the speed at which results pages load. When I executed an identical search on both pages, Google’s results appeared in less than a second and Bing’s again took several times longer. I’d consider such a difference in the metric known in tech circles as “Teh Snappy” a dealbreaker, but for two factors:

  1. Bing organizes its search results, particularly product and video search results, in interesting ways. I have yet to properly experiment with this.
  2. Microsoft pays users 6 to use their search engine to shop for products. Yay, money.

So for now, I’ll occasionally use Bing for net searches for the sake of variety and experimentation, and I always use Bing as a gateway to eBay or other online vendors, so that I get money back for purchases made (amounts vary — I think the cashback for eBay purchases is around 8%). 25% of the purchase price of my iPhone was given back to me due to my use of this cashback feature back when the engine was called “Live Search”. I like to think that Microsoft paid me to buy an iPhone, but the reality is probably much more complicated.

To my mind, Bing isn’t a home run, but it’s interesting, particularly if they continue to pay me to use it. That may sound like faint and cynical praise, but it’s more than I can say of any search engine that’s tried to compete with Google in years. I look forward to seeing how the engine develops.

  1. I remember being partial to huskysearch and metacrawler in the days pre-Google. ↩︎
  2. This can probably be read as a tacit acknowledgement by Microsoft that there are few users of the previous incarnations of the search engine to confuse. Bing! ↩︎
  3. Or perhaps the name change is just Microsoft’s way of stimulating the “product branding consultant” sector of the economy. Bing! ↩︎
  4. And also as the sole sponsored result. Microsoft is paying to advertise their search engine in the search results of their chief competitor’s search engine. ↩︎
  5. If Mr. Crosby is really a more popular result than the article on their search engine, MSFT’s marketing team needs to work harder. Perhaps an ad in which a couple listen to a Bing Crosby song and then the wife vomits on the husband? Bing! ↩︎
  6. Or do vendors who list products on Bing pay users for using Microsoft’s search engine to find their products? I’m not exactly sure where the money comes from or why. ↩︎