
The “kill” button is just one of the
iPhone’s most innovative new features.
A while back, when rumors of an Apple cell phone began circulating, I only allowed myself low expectations. Given how uninteresting the
Motorola Rokr was (100 song limit?!), and how crazy the rumors sounded, I figured this was a reasonable move. There were signs of something good in the offing –Apple’s late-2005 patent filing for a
touch-screen interface that displayed a “virtual scroll wheel” was a dead giveaway that this technology would be in future Apple handheld devices, but other details were less easy to guess, and the guesses rampant on the net sounded outlandish. I assumed that other rumors to be just rumors, especially the one which stated that the phone would be a full-on smartphone that runs a version of OS X, or that it would have WiFi networking built in. What pie-in-the-sky thinking. I expected only a fairly simple but nice phone with a touch-screen interface paired with an iPod nano, basically a phone with 8Gb of music on board. Maybe smartphone features would come in a later edition. I didn’t expect WiFi to ever be included.
There were reasons for my skepticism about WiFI. Cell phone companies do not love everything about smartphones, specifically they don’t like smartphones that they can’t control, that might not allow them to take a cut of everything. Rumor has it that the Rokr couldn’t buy songs from iTunes because the carriers wouldn’t allow it unless the price per song was jacked up and they could get a huge cut. It is rumored that similar pressure from carriers is the reason the Palm Treos lack WiFi. Palm actually makes a SD-card WiFi adapter for their PDAs, but for some reason never released a driver to make this device work in their Treo smartphones. The carriers control the cell phone market. As a cell phone manufacturer you’re screwed if Sprint, for example, says they won’t carry your smartphone in their stores if you allow the phone to access WiFi networks, because they worry that consumers will install Skype or other voice-over-IP software (VOIP) and use it over wireless networks rather than paying for minutes. Some Windows Mobile phones work with WiFi, maybe Microsoft had enough clout to push that past the carriers, I’m really not sure how that happened.

I was quite wrong. The Apple iPhone really is a step up from the Newton MP2000, and has a lower price.
In any case, I was wrong to lower my expectations for Apple’s iPhone, because
the cell phone Apple has announced sounds terrific. Here’s a rundown of my thoughts on the features of the announced device:
- “Runs OS X” - Obviously a form of OS X slimmed down and optimized for the phone, but judging from descriptions of the presentation it still includes some graphics acceleration. Hopefully it will be possible to develop for the iPhone using Apple’s free developer tools, in which case I’d expect a PalmOS emulator to be ported to the iPhone in short order. This would make thousands of great PDA apps available at once. I am especially hopeful that this happens so that (were I to purchase an iPhone) I could run Plecosoft’s great Chinese dictionary. If it is really running OS X, I look forward to trying Terminal.app on it. I’ve wanted a good cell phone that runs Unix for a long time.
- Includes the Safari web browser, Widgets, iTunes, Email, and a Google Maps application - This all sounds good. Widgets are usually little bits of Javascript and HTML cobbled together to make tiny apps, the fact that support for them is included on the phone makes me optimistic about the future availability of lots of useful user-written applications. Negative commenters on engadget who diss the Google Maps support have obviously never tried to use Google Maps from a smartphone before. The Google Maps website is so Javascript-intensive that it brings all smartphones to their knees.
- Well designed call and voicemail interfaces - It’s difficult to watch Apple’s flash demos of the UI and not get excited. Finally a phone UI that makes it possible to listen to voicemail messages out of order, or properly deal with incoming calls during a conversation. My Treo doesn’t get either of these right.
- 3.5-inch widescreen 480 x 320 display - Sounds gorgeous, and might make this the highest res cell phone in existence, assuming someone doesn’t beat it before the expected release date in June. Resolution isn’t just a matter of flashiness, but it a utilitarian matter if you plan to read much text or browse websites. Every day I thank the cell phone gods for the 320×320 display on the secondhand Treo 650 I bought here in China (very useful with the aforementioned Plecodict dictionary).
- An actual 3.5mm headphone plug - It would be very annoying to have to use an adapter to be able to plug non-cell-phone headphones into this phone. This is a feature that other smartphone manufacturers constantly overlook (I’m pointing at you PalmOne, though I doubt you’re alone in this).
- Bluetooth, WiFi - Bluetooth was expected, but WiFi which “automatically engages when in range” is a great thing. This will be great when Skype is available for the phone, or someone writes a SIP client so that we can all use this phone with our home servers running the Asterix PBX.
- Proximity sensor disables touchscreen and display when device is held to user’s face - Great feature! I wish my Treo was this intelligent, but instead it runs down the battery keeping the display on during calls, and I can accidentally hang up a call by hitting the hang up button with my chin. I tried an extension that blanks the Treo screen during calls, but it’s sometimes useful to pull the phone from your ear and check something on the display.
- Free push email from Yahoo - and likely from everyone else soon after launch I’d guess once people sort out the likely very simple protocol. Nail in the coffin for Blackberry? Well, those Blackberry phones do have other features, but given the availability of Chattermail for Palm, and now push email on the Apple iPhone, Blackberry’s push-email feature no longer sounds like the one feature that makes that particular device essential for every business executive with ADHD.
- Touchscreen keyboard - I’m a little less excited about this. I’ll have to try it in person. I suppose the screen would have been smaller, or the device thicker, had there been a real keyboard included. My past experience with touchscreens has been that it’s difficult to hit keys very precisely without a stylus, and kayboard buttons give useful tactile feedback that will be missing here. I’m not excited, but have learned my lesson about low expectations. Given how well the iPod’s touchpad interfaces work (Apple even managed to cram a tiny piezo speaker in the iPod nano just to make barely perceptible but surprisingly useful feedback noises while you use that device’s interface), I’d expect that if anyone can finally make a usable touchscreen interface it will be Apple.
- $499 on a two-year Cingular contract for 4Gb model - Price sounds high, but smartphones are expensive. The Treo 700p on Sprint was only $100 less, and it only has 128Mb of built-in memory.
- GSM/EDGE - These are the largest and most available voice and data networks right now, worldwide. I’d be surprised if there isn’t also a CDMA/EVDO version of this phone in the near future, everyone always launches with one network and carrier at first due to exclusive deals that last a couple of months. I’m happy Apple first launched with a GSM rather CDMA model, it means the phone will be usable in China and Europe by popping in a local SIM card as soon as people figure out how to undo the carrier lock, which will happen quickly.
- 5 hours talk time - That’s decent battery life, in line with most other phones. It’d be nice to know how many days of standby.
- 4.5 inches by 2.4 inches by 11.6mm - That’s very very tiny and thin. Compare to the thickness of the Motorola Razr V3 at 13.9mm thick and Slvr at 11.5mm. The rounded edges on the iPhone will also likely make it easy to slide into and out of pockets.
I’m impressed. If it’s easy to develop software for this phone, and Chinese language support is forthcoming, and the touchscreen isn’t a pain, and I feel like I can afford one, and my Treo 650 falls down a well, I’ll consider one of these.